Monday, February 25, 2013

KI SISA – CLEARING THE CONFUSION

The sin of the Golden Calf is one of the most difficult to comprehend episodes in the Torah. The commentaries discuss at length how the Jewish people could stumble in such a severe sin just forty days after the Revelation at Sinai. The events that led up to the sin are similarly clothed in mystery. In particular, the account of how the people came to believe that Moshe Rabbeinu had died Is very difficult to understand: The Torah tells us that the people miscalculated when Moshe would return, believing he should come back one day earlier than was in fact the case. The Gemara elaborates on the details of this mistake. It tells us that the Satan showed them an image of Moshe no longer alive. When they saw this they panicked and demanded that Aaron create for them a new medium through whom they could relate to G-d. One of the difficulties in this passage is the method in which the Satan caused them to sin by showing them an image. Nowhere do see we such a tactic used in other incidents in the Torah. Normally a person sins because he would rationalize that what he was doing was correct. What is the nature of this form of persuasion and why was it necessary for the Satan to show them such an image instead of using the normal methods of persuasion? Rav Chaim of Volozhin in his classic work, Nefesh HaChaim answers these questions in the course of his discussion on the nature of the yetser hara (evil inclination). In order to do this, he first explains the sin of Adam and Chava, and ends by showing how the events of Mattan Torah (the Giving of the Torah) and the Golden Calf paralleled the state of Adam and Chava before the sin and after the sin: He begins with an analysis of Adam and Chava’s state before the sin: Chazal tell us that before the sin, mankind did not have a yetser hara, yet this does not mean that he did not have free will. He related to evil - in his situation in the form of the nachash (snake) - as something that was totally outside of himself. Its goal was to somehow persuade him to perform an act that was clearly abhorrent to him. The Nefesh HaChaim compares it to a person deciding whether he should step into a fire. However, somehow, the nachash was able to seduce Chava into eating from the fruit of the knowledge of Good and Evil. By eating from this tree, Adam and Chava brought the yetser hara into themselves. This means that they now constituted of a combination of the good that emanated from their pure soul, and the evil that came from the yetser hara. The result of this was that they were now subject to the main weapon of the yetser hara; confusion. When a person knows that something is clearly wrong he will not do it. The yetser hara’s tactic is to convince him that this sin is actually not a sin at all, in fact it is the correct thing to do. In this vein, Chazal tell us that a person only sins when a ruach shtus overtakes him – this means that he loses touch with his sense of right and wrong and therefore does the wrong thing, whilst convincing himself that it is actually the right thing to do. The Nefesh HaChaim continues that this state of being continued until Mattan Torah. The Gemara states that the ‘poison’ that Chava ingested when she sinned (ie. the yetser hara) was completely negated when the Jewish people stood at Har Sinai. In this way, the Jewish people returned to the level of Adam before the sin. At this point in time, the people would be able to live eternally as was the case with Adam before he ate from the tree. With this understanding of the state of the people after Mattan Torah, the Nefesh HaChaim explains why the Satan showed an image to the people. They were on such a high level that there was no yetser hara inside them. Accordingly, the yetser hara could not trick them with its regular weapon of internal confusion. Rather, it had to persuade them externally, in the same way that the nachash did with Chava. When the people succumbed to the Satan’s persuasion, the ‘poison’ from the sin returned to them and the yetser hara once again dwelled within them. We have seen how the Satan was forced to revert to unorthodox methods of persuasion in order to cause the Jewish people to sin with the Golden Calf. However, after they sinned, the Satan re-entered the very being of each person, leaving us with the difficult task of trying to discern the good inside of us from the evil. The yetser hara’s main tool now is to convince us that what we are doing is actually permitted or even a Mitzvo. For example, the Chofetz Chaim zt”l pointed out that many people were speaking lashon hara with the justification that this particular thing they were saying was permissible; or that it was permitted to speak lashon hara about that particular person. The lashon hara speaker did not think he was speaking lashon hara, rather he rationalized that what he was saying did not constitute forbidden speech. In this vein, the Baal HaTania points out that if one were to offer an observant person a large amount of money to speak lashon hara, he will refuse. This is because he intellectually recognizes that no amount of money is worth transgressing a Mitzvo. Yet the same person will, on another occasion, speak lashon hara for no monetary gain! This is because he convinces himself that he is not speaking lashon hara at all. How can a person begin the long journey in discerning between the yetser tov and the yetser hara that is inside of him? One vital tool is Torah learning. If a person learns the laws of lashon hara, for example he will find it much harder to rationalize that what he is saying is permissible. Likewise, learning Mussar helps a person understand how his yetser hara works, and act accordingly. The other essential tool is that of Cheshbon HaNefesh (accounting of the soul). This involves a regular analysis of one’s actions and can enable a person to look back and rationally analyze the true nature of his actions. It is highly recommended to seek assistance in how to do Cheshbon HaNefesh in the proper way. With a concerted and long-term effort at learning Torah and self-analysis a person can begin the long journey back to gaining true clarity as to good and evil.

Wednesday, February 20, 2013

MEGILLA – RASHI INSIGHTS

Megilla Esther, 1:1: “And it was in the days of Achashverosh: he is Achashverosh who ruled from Hodu to Cush over a hundred and twenty seven provinces.” Rashi, 1:1: sv. He is Achashverosh: He [remained] in his evil from the beginning until the end. In the first verse in the Megilla, Rashi reveals an allusion to the nature of King Achashverosh, one of the main characters in the story. He teaches us that Achashverosh was an evil person at the beginning of the story and remained evil till the very end. Two questions arise: Firstly, every detail in the Megilla teaches us a message that is connected to the theme of Purim – in what way is the fact that Achashverosh remained evil relevant to the lessons of Purim? Secondly, why, of all the many reshaim who feature in the Tanach is Achashverosh one of the only ones to be singled out for this particular criticism? By answering the second question we can then understand the first as well. It seems that there are two very significant factors that can cause a wayward person to change his ways; the first is exposure to righteous people. The Torah instructs us to cleave to talmidei chachamim and Chazal speak at length of the importance of spending as much time as possible with great people because one can learn from their righteous behavior and see first-hand the results of living a spiritual life. A second possible catalyst for teshuva is the events surrounding us; when a person is involved in events that seem to be guided by the Divine Hand, he has the opportunity to respond to the Divine message and change his ways. Achashverosh merited both opportunities; He married the righteous Esther, whose greatness could not have been hidden from him despite her secretive nature. Moreover, his main advisor towards the end of his life was Mordechai HaTzadik, one of the greatest Sages of the time. Achashverosh also had the good fortune to be one of the players in the remarkable Purim story - the account of how the very existence of the Jewish people was threatened, and yet everything was miraculously turned on its head. It would be difficult to not be positively affected by such great people and by being part of such a miraculous story. Yet Achashverosh remained the same, greedy, selfish person at the end of the story and indeed the end of his life. One proof of this is mentioned by the Gemara is found in one of the very last verses in the Megilla: “And King Achashverosh placed a tax on the land and the islands.” The commentaries explain that when he married Esther he reduced the taxes on his Kingdom so that her home nation might reveal itself to him in order to benefit further from its new connection to the King. At the end of the story he knew her identity, therefore he raised the taxes again. This demonstrates that at the climax of the Purim story all Achashverosh could think about was money. Another indication that he remained evil is that he never committed to rebuilding the second Temple despite the great benefits he derived from Mordechai and Esther. We can now understand the connection between Achashverosh’s flaw and the Purim story. The lesson of Purim is to see the Divine Providence even in a time of Hester Panim (when HaShem’s Presence is hidden) and to increase our awareness of HaShem in our own lives. Yet it is insufficient if that newfound recognition remains in the realm of the mind and heart. It must bring about an enhancement in one’s Avodas HaShem. The example of Achashverosh teaches us how not to respond to Divine Providence – remaining oblivious to HaShem’s messages and engulfed in base lusts and desires.

Monday, February 18, 2013

PURIM - MISHLOACH MANOS AND MATANOS L’EVYONIM

One of the unique features of Purim, are the mitzvos concerning giving to one’s fellow Jew. We are obligated to give mishloach manos and matanas la’evyonim . There is no other festival in which there is a similar obligation of chessed (kindness). What is the connection between these mitzvos and the story of Purim? This question can be answered by analyzing of some of the passukim in the Megilla. When Haman approaches Achashverosh with his plan to destroy the Jewish people, he outlines why they do not deserve to be kept alive. “And Haman said to King Acharshverosh, there is one nation scattered and dispersed (mefurad) among the people.” The commentaries explain that Haman was making an accurate criticism of the Jewish people, one which helped convince the King that they would not be protected by HaShem. Haman was arguing that the Jewish people were not unified and accordingly, they were lacking the Divine protection that they merited when they were unified. Accordingly, one of the most important ways of removing the decree of destruction from Above , was to renew the sense of unity amongst the Jewish people. Rav Yonasan Ebeshitz zt”l explains that this was the intention of Esther when she instructed Mordechai how to overturn the decree. “Go, assemble all the Jews to be found in Shushan, and fast for me.” She recognized that only a unified effort could overturn the decree. Indeed, this approach succeeded. The Vilna Gaon zt”l demonstrates in a number of passukim, that the Jewish people displayed great unity when they finally took the upper hand against their enemies. “The rest of the Jews throughout the King’s provinces gathered together and defended themselves (amad al nafsham)..” The Vilna Gaon notes the word ‘amad’ is in the singular form, as opposed to the plural form of ‘amdu’. This, he writes, demonstrates that they were completely unified, as if they were one entity. Soon after, the Megilla informs us that Mordechai instituted the festival of Purim. In reaction, it tells us that, “The Jews undertook (kibel) to continue the practice they had begun..” Again, the word, ‘kibel’ is in the singular form, further demonstrating that they were unified. Finally, the Sifsei Chaim adds a similar explanation to the famous verse in which, according to Chazal , the Jewish people willingly accepted the Torah: “They fulfilled (kiymu) and accepted (kiblu) upon themselves…to observe these two days…” The would kiblu is read in the plural form, however it is written in the singular ‘kibel’, again alluding to the fact that they accepted the Torah in complete unity. With this understanding of the significance of unity in the Purim story, it is easy to understand why Chazal instituted mitzvos in the realm of bein adam lechaveiro. Purim reminds us of the importance of unity amongst the Jewish people. Giving to one’s fellow Jew is an excellent tool to help us care more about them. Moreover, it is not enough for a person to give to one’s friends alone, he must not ignore those who are far less fortunate - the destitute people who are easily forgotten about. Therefore, in addition to Mishloach Manos, Chazal instructed us in matanos la‘evyonim.. We now understand that disunity was a key factor in the decree against the Jews, and how increasing unity played a significant role in the removal of the decree. However, it remains unclear as to why the Jews were so lacking in unity at this time, and how they were able to rectify this flaw. The Sifsei Chaim addresses this issue by bringing the explanation of Rabbeinu Yonah on a passuk in Mishlei. Shlomo HaMelech writes: “Taava yevakesh, nifrad ” Rabbeinu Yonah explains this to mean that a person who follow his desires, will become alienated from his friends. This is because natural desires are inherently self-serving and clash with the desires of everyone else. Accordingly, a person who only cares about satisfying his desires will have divergent goals from the people around him. Consequently, a society that is full of such people will not possess any unity. Haman understood that the Jewish people had become influenced by the ideologies and desires of the various nations that they dwelled in, accordingly he stressed to the King that the Jewish people were “spread out and dispersed among the nations.” Sifsei Chaim explains that he deliberately emphasized the fact that they were among the nations, because this was the cause of their disunity. Each Jew’s goals were influenced by those of the surrounding societies, therefore there was no unity amongst the Jewish people as a whole. Rabbeinu Yonah continues by explaining that the key to unity is a common goal - that of serving HaShem. The Jewish people can only achieve their role in the world by sharing this common purpose. When this takes place, problems of machlokes and damaging competition dissipate, allowing the people to focus all their efforts on doing HaShem’s will. This is what famously occurred before the Giving of the Torah at Har Sinai. Chazal tell us that they were unified to the extent that they were “like one man with one heart”. It was no coincidence that they attained this level of harmony at Har Sinai. It enabled them to focus all their energies on accepting the Torah; had they been involved in disputes, they would have been unable to properly accept the Torah. Esther recognized that the disunity of the Jewish people was caused by their divergent goals, and that taiva played a key role in causing this disunity. Accordingly, she instructed that the people should gather together in the context of a fast. As well as the obvious reasons for fasting, abstaining from physical enjoyment can weaken a person’s attachment to his physical desires and help him focus on Avodas HaShem. In this way, it seems that the fast helped the people reconnect with their true goal of doing HaShem’s will. Similarly, it seems that it is no coincidence that the unity they Jews achieved when they fought their enemies, came about after fasting on the 13th of Adar. Again, the fasting strengthened their ability to weaken their own selfish desires and focus on the single goal of fulfilling Ratson HaShem. Morever, this level of unity enabled them to re-accept the Torah just as they had done at Sinai. With this insight into the connection between weakening of taiva and unity, we can now attain a deeper understanding of mishloach manos and matanos la’evyonim. In order to attain the level of unity that the Jews reached, we must detach ourselves from our natural taivas. That is always a difficult task, and this is even more so, the case on Purim when we greatly involve ourselves in the physical world. Giving gifts and money to our fellow Jew is an excellent way of ensuring that we do not get pulled down into the selfishness that results from following one’s taiva. By thinking about, and giving to, other people, we can ensure that our eating and drinking help bring us closer to HaShem and not further from Him. Purim is a time when we remember the importance of unity to the Jewish people. May we merit to focus all our energies on the common goal of fulfilling HaShem’s ratson.

TETZAVEH - THE MEIL AND THE KETORES

"You shall make the Robe of the Ephod entirely of turquoise wool.... You shall make on its hem pomegranates of turquoise, purple, and scarlet wool, on its hem all around, and gold bells between them, all around; a gold bell and a pomegranate, a gold bell and a pomegranate on the hem of the robe, all around. " One of the Vestements of the Kohen Gadol was the Meil, a robe that was adorned with bells and rang whenever the Kohen Gadol walked. The Gemara in Arachin discusses how all of the Kohen Gadol's Vestements atoned for a particular aveiro; the meil atoned for the sin of lashon hara. The Gemara explains that the meil, which made a loud kol (sound) should atone for lashon hara which makes a loud kol. However, the Gemara brings a seemingly contradictory braissa that says that the ketores (incense) that was used in the Mishkan atones for lashon hara. It answers that there are two different types of lashon hara; the ketores atones for a more 'quiet' form lashon hara, when the speaker hides his true feelings from the subject of his criticism and therefore the 'victim' of the lashon hara has no awareness that someone is criticizing him. In contrast, the lashon hara that is atoned for by the meil is characterized by the speaker making no secret of his true feelings about the victim to the extent that the victim is very likely to be aware of what is being said about him . However, this explanation of the Gemara seems to pose a new difficulty; why is it necessary for there to be two separate functions of the Mishkan to atone for the single sin of lashon hara; why can't either the meil or the ketores atone for both 'loud' and 'quiet' lashon hara? Moreover, it would seem that loud lashon hara is significantly more damaging than 'quiet' lashon hara. Therefore, if the meil has the power to atone for the more severe form of lashon hara, then it should surely be able to atone for the seemingly less damaging 'quiet' lashon hara? In order to answer this question it is necessary to understand more specifically the negative aspects of these two forms of lashon hara: Loud lashon hara is very damaging in that the victim is aware of the evil speech that is directed towards him and this naturally causes him great pain. In this aspect, loud lashon hara is considered more destructive than its quieter counterpart. However, there is a certain way in which 'quiet' lashon hara is more pernicious than loud lashon hara. Quiet lashon hara is characterized by the perpetrator of this grave sin behaving in a two-faced manner towards his victim; in front of him he is very friendly, but behind his back he slanders him mercilessly and instructs the listeners not to reveal his true feelings to his unfortunate fellow. Since the victim is totally unaware that he is being vilified, he makes no efforts to protect himself from these attacks and they may continue unabated. In contrast, the victim of 'loud' lashon hara is far more likely to find out about the lashon hara spoken about him, consequently he will be able to protect himself. With this understanding we can now explain why it is necessary for there to be two separate functions of the Mishkan to atone for lashon hara. Each form of lashon hara is more detrimental in some way than the other. Consequently, whilst the meil has the capacity to atone for the damaging aspect of 'loud' lashon hara it cannot atone for the harm caused by quiet lashon hara. Similarly, the ketores can atone for the pernicious features of 'quiet' lashon hara but it cannot do so for the areas in which 'loud' lashon hara is more damaging. What is particularly striking about this explanation is that in some ways speaking lashon hara in a hidden fashion is worse than doing so in a blatant manner. The Chofetz Chaim zt"l discusses how speaking lashon hara of the 'quiet' kind can also involve a transgression of the Mitzvo, "do not hate your brother in your heart (loh sisna es achicha bilvavecha) ." The simple understanding of this Mitzvo is that one only transgresses it when he keeps his hatred in his heart and does not reveal it to anyone, including the subject of his hatred. However, if he expresses his hatred even in a negative way, he does not transgress 'loh sisna' because he did not keep the hatred in his heart . The Chofetz Chaim argues that this is not necessarily the case; a person may hate his fellow and tells others of his hatred, but act towards him in a friendly manner. This, the Chofetz Chaim writes, is also a transgression of keeping hatred in one's heart. He explains that the root of the sin of keeping hatred in one's heart is that the subject of the hatred is unable to protect himself from the person who despises him. Consequently, if the 'hater' hides his true feelings to his fellow he is guilty of loh sisna even if he tells others about his hatred. We see from the Chofetz Chaim the above concept that 'quiet' lashon hara has a particularly insidious aspect to it, in that its victim is totally unable to protect himself from the silent bombardments that he is subjected to. There may be occasions in a person's life where he develops a dislike for someone. It is self-evident that this loathing does not justify speaking lashon hara. We learn further from the Gemara in Arachin that acting towards him in a two-faced manner makes the lashon hara even more destructive. Chazal tell us that Yosef's brothers were wrong in hating him, but to their credit they did not act in a hypocritical manner towards him. The lesson we derive from the brothers' behavior towards Yosef that whilst it is wrong to hate someone, it is far worse to hide that hatred of him and speak badly about him behind his back. This hanhago only succeeds in causing enmity and machlokes. The ideal course of action is to try to resolve the situation by speaking to the subject of his hatred in a calm and reasonable manner and strive to resolve the issue in a mature fashion. By acting in an honest and candid manner, one can greatly improve his relationships with those around him.

תצווה – שורש לשון הרע

בס"ד חז"ל אומרים שבגדי הקודש של הכהן הגדול היוו כפרה לחטאיהם של כלל ישראל. ביניהם המעיל, שמכפר על חטא לשון הרע. מה שהיה מיוחד ביותר במעיל הוא היותו כליל תכלת – צבע המזכיר את כסא הכבוד . כיצד קשור צבעו התכלת של המעיל לכפרה על לשון הרע? ה"חפץ חיים" זצ"ל מסביר זאת על פי דברי התנא דבי אליהו, שאומר שדברי לשון הרע שאדם אומר עולים למעלה עד לכסא הכבוד. הכוונה בכך היא שאדם המדבר לשון הרע יעמוד על כך לדין בפני כסא הכבוד. מעיל התכלת של הכהן הגדול משמש כתזכורת לאדם שיש במילים שבפיו כוח רוחני גדול מאד . הודות להתעוררות העצומה שחלה בעניין שמירת הלשון, קיימת כיום מודעות גבוהה הרבה יותר מאשר פעם להלכות לשון הרע ולהשקפות הנלוות לכך. עם זאת, חטא לשון הרע נשאר אחד החטאים הקשים ביותר להימנע מהם, וישנן כמה סיבות לכך, כמו העובדה שאנו מדברים כל כך הרבה במשך היום, וקיים לחץ חברתי חזק המקשה מאד על כל אחד להימנע מכל דיבור שלילי. מכל מקום, ישנו גורם נוסף ללשון הרע שורשי הרבה יותר, ועמוק, והוא העומד מאחורי רבים מאד מדיבורי לשון הרע. הלכות לשון הרע מתיחסות לעובדה ש שבני אדם בטבעם שואבים הנאה כלשהיא מדיבור שלילי על זולתם – ניתן לראות זאת מהלכות לשון הרע לתועלת: ישנם מקרים בהם מותר ואף צריך לדבר לשון הרע על מנת למנוע נזק. אולם גם במקרה כזה, אסור לדבר אם יש הנאה כלשהי למספר מהדיבור בגנות האדם השני. קשה להבין זאת - ישנם חטאים רבים אליהם יש יצר הרע מובהק וברור, כגון גילוי עריות, אולם קשה להגדיר הנאה ממשית, מוחשית וברורה הנובעת מדיבור לשון הרע. ממה נובע אפוא אותו סחף לדיבורים אסורים על הזולת? נראה שהמקור להנאה מדיבורי לשון הרע היא שדיבורים אלה מעניקים חיזוק מדומה לערך העצמי של האדם: כאשר אדם מרגיש חסר בערכו העצמי, עומדות בפניו שתי אפשרויות כיצד לחזק את ערכו בעיני עצמו – אחת היא להתחיל לפעול ולעשות מעשים חשובים ומועילים ובכך לפתח ולרומם את אישיותו. בדרך זו כל אדם מרגיש סיפוק, הגשמה עצמית וערך עצמי גבוה. מצד שני, ישנה גם דרך אחרת, שלכאורה קלה יותר; כל אדם נוטה להעריך את עצמו ביחס לזולת, ולכן על פי רוב הערך העצמי של האדם תלוי מאד באופן בו הוא משווה את עצמו לסובבים אותו. כאשר הוא מעביר דברי גנאי וביקורת על הזולת הוא משפיל את הזולת, ובכך באופן אוטומטי הוא רואה את עצמו במקום גבוה יותר ומעודד יותר בהשוואה לסביבה. לדוגמא, אם אדם מרגיש על עצמו שהוא אינו פיקח במיוחד, כאשר הוא מבקר אדם אחר בנושא זה בדיוק, הוא מרגיש ביחס לעצמו תחושה טובה יותר והערכה גדולה יותר למידת הפקחות שלו הוא. נראה שזהו ההסבר לדברי חז"ל האומרים שאדם המדבר רע על זולתו – הוא בעצמו לקוי בדיוק באותו נושא. חז"ל בחכמתם הכירו את הצורך הפסיכולוגי של האדם להרגיש נוח עם עצמו , וידעו שאחת הדרכים העיקריות בהם אדם דואג לעצמו לתחושה זו היא על ידי השפלת הזולת באותם שטחים בדיוק בהם הוא חלש בעצמו. ודאי שאותו חיזוק לערך העצמי של האדם, הנובע מדיבורי לשון הרע אסורים הוא חיזוק מדומה מאד וקצר טווח. לאחר זמן קצר מאד תשוב למדבר אותה תחושת חסר ואי נוחות עם עצמו, ואז הוא שוב ירגיש צורך לדבר רע על מישהו אחר כדי לחזק את עצמו בחזרה. כל אדם שניסה אי פעם להימנע מדיבור לשון הרע שעמד על שפתיו, יכול להעיד שכאשר הוא עמד בניסיון והשאיר את המילים ההרסניות בתוכו, הוא לא חש כל חסר לאחר מכן, אלא להיפך, תחושה אחרת מגיעה, הרגשה טובה מאד, תחושת ערך עצמי וסיפוק ממימוש היכולת לנהוג באופן הנכון. ישנם שני לימודים חשובה שניתן ללמוד מהבנת רעיון זה. ראשית אנו חייבים לעמוד על המשמר ביתר זהירות ולבדוק אחר כוונתנו האמיתית כאשר אנו מדברים דברי לשון הרע לתועלת. נושא זה חשוב במיוחד כאשר מדובר על הנושא העדין מאד של דברי ביקורת על קבוצות או דעות אחרות בתוך היהדות. ראש ישיבת מנצ'סטר, הר' סגל זצ"ל, אמר פעם שרק צדיקים גדולים רשאים למתוח ביקורת על קבוצות אחרות. סיבה אחת לכך היא שהצדיקים אינם מרגישים כל חסר בערך עצמי, או חוסר בטחון עצמי, וממילא אין בהם את אותו צורך פסיכולוגי אישי למתוח דברי ביקורת על אחרים. לעומת זאת, כל אדם אחר נוטה בטבעו לתחושת ערך עצמי נמוך, ועלול להביע טענות נכונות אולי על אותם אלה שאינו מסכים עם דעותיהם, אבל המניע שלו אינו לשם שמים כלל ועיקר. מעשה זה נחשב ללשון הרע מדאורייתא, וודאי חכם יותר יהיה לאמץ את דבריו של הרב סגל ולעולם לא להסתכן בעבירה על חטא חמור כל כך. הלימוד השני הוא שאם אנו מזהים בתוכנו את התאווה להמעיט בערך הזולת, עלינו לעשות חשבון נפש ולבדוק מהו המקור לכך. פעמים רבות תאווה זו נובעת מחוסר בהערכה העצמית. ובמקום להשפיל את הזולת, טוב יותר נעשה עם ניטיב עם עצמנו ועם ערכנו העצמי על ידי עבודת המידות, והשקעת מאמצים לפעול יותר, לתת יותר ולהועיל לכל החברה כולה. מי ייתכן וכולנו נזכה לטהרת הלשון, וללמוד את הלימוד שמלמדנו המעיל.

פורים – אל יאוש

הגמרא אומרת שהגזירה הנוראה להשמיד, להרוג ולאבד את כל העם היהודי הייתה עונש על שהשתתפו בסעודתו של אחשוורוש . במשך תקופת בית שני, היו הנביאים מוכיחים את עם ישראל ללא הרף על חטאיהם ומעשיהם הרעים, כולל החטא החמור של עבודה זרה, ובכל זאת מעולם לא נגזרה עליהם גזירה קשה כל כך של השמדה מוחלטת. מדוע על חטא זה, הנראה לכאורה פחות חמור – נענשו בעונש כה נורא? על מנת לענות על שאלה זו, נעיין ונבדוק מה הוביל את אחשוורוש להחליט לקיים את משתהו הראותני. חז"ל אומרים שהשתייה הוגשה בכלי קודש מבית המקדש. ואחשוורוש בעצמו – לבוש היה בבגדי כהן גדול. לשם נהג כך? איזו מטרה רצה להשיג במעשיו אלו? ר' חיים הלפרן שליט"א מסביר שעד אותו משתה, היה אחשוורוש מוטרד מנבואתו של ירמיהו בדבר חזרתם העתידית של היהודים לארצם, ובניית בית המקדש מחדש לאחר שבעים שנות הגלות. הוא חישב ומצא ש-70 השנים מסתיימות – ועדיין לא נראה כל סימן להתגשמות הנבואה. לכן, הוא ערך את המשתה בדיוק ביום בו על פי חשבונו אמורה להסתיים תקופה זו, ואז ניסה לשכנע את היהודים שאפסה תקוותם לגאולה ולבניין בית המקדש, חלף זאת כדאי להם כעת להיאחז במלכותו וממנה לשאוב את כל צרכיהם. לכן, הוא התלבש ככהן גדול – להראות שהוא הפך להיות מנהיגם החדש, והשתמש בכלי המקדש כדי לגרום להם להבין ששוב אין מה לצפות לבניין בית המקדש בירושלים . למרבה הצער, היהודים קבלו את המסר שניסה אחשוורוש להעביר להם, הצטרפו ברצון רב לסעודתו, ואף שתו בכלי הקודש. הם איבדו את תקוותם ואמונתם. הם נטשו מאחור את שאיפתם הגדולה לבית מקדש שני, ופנו לעתיד שונה, להיות אזרחים הנאמנים לאימפריה הפרסית ולמלך אחשוורש. המשמעות האמיתית של החלטתם היתה לנטוש, מתוך יאוש את תפקידו המיוחד של העם היהודי, שאמור להיות לאור לכל עמי הארץ. מבחינתם, אפסה כל תקווה לחזרה לארץ ישראל ולבניין בית המקדש. הם לא הבינו כי הזכות היחידה לקיומו של העם היהודי היא קיום תפקידם המיוחד בעולמו של הקב"ה. ה' בחר בעם ישראל מכל העמים בזכות רצונם להיות עם סגולה, המלמד את העולם כולו לדעת את ה'. זניחת תפקידם הייחודי גרמה לתוצאה ישירה: אבדן זכות קיומם. עונשם היה מידה כנגד מידה, והם נדונו לכליה . כיצד ניצלו היהודים מסכנה עצומה זו בה היו נתונים – סכנת כליה מוחלטת? הגמרא מספרת על חילופי הדברים בין מרדכי להמן בעת שהגיע המן להודיע למרדכי על הכבוד שחפץ המלך להעניק לו. המן מצא את מרדכי יושב ולומד תורה. שאלו המן: "מה אתה לומד?" ענה: "כאשר בית המקדש היה קיים, אדם שהקריב קרבן מנחה היה מביא קומץ סולת, וחטאו היה מתכפר" אמר לו המן: "קומץ הסולת שלכם הוא שיעמוד כנגד עשרת אלפים ככר הכסף שלי" . לכאורה, קשה להבין גמרא זו. מה משמעות יש לנושא בו עסק מרדכי, ומדוע דווקא תשובה זו גרמה להמן להבין שהוא ינוצח בסופו של דבר? הר' מפונוביז' מסביר שהמן ידע שכל סיכוייו להצליח במזימתו מבוססים על חטאם של היהודים בסעודתו של אחשווורוש. כאשר ראה את מרדכי מלמד הלכות השייכות רק כאשר בית המקדש קיים, הוא הבין שעם ישראל חזר בתשובה, ושוב בוערת בלב כל אחד מהם השאיפה לבניין בית המקדש. הם שבו להאמין שהם יכולים להמשיך בתפקידם הייחודי כ"אור לכל העמים" המן הבין שאם היהודים לא התייאשו ולא נטשו את האמונה, הקב"ה לא יעזבם לעולם. הניסיון בו התנסו היהודים בימים ההם היה לשמור על התקווה והאמונה גם בזמני ניסיון קשים. ניסיון זה קיים גם בזמן הזה, ואם חלילה אנו נופלים לחולשה בנושא זה, אויבינו שואבים מכך כוח ועידוד מחודש למטרותיהם הזדוניות. מסופר על טרוריסט ערבי שתיאר את תקופת היותו נתון בכלא הישראלי, זו אשר מיד לאחריה הוא שב למעשיו המושחתים, ואפילו בהתלהבות גדולה יותר. הוא אמר שבהיותו בכלא, גמלה בליבו ההחלטה לותר על ה"קריירה" שלו כטרוריסט, באשר הוא חש שגם מעשיו האלימים ביותר לא יצליחו במטרת העל – לכלות את ישראל. אולם, פעם אחת, בחג הפסח הוא ראה שומר ישראלי אוכל פיתה. הערבי ידע מאיסור אכילת חמץ בפסח ולכן הוא שאל את השומר מדוע הוא אינו מקיים את ההלכה. השומר ענה שֶחוקים והלכות אלה איבדו כבר את תוקפם וחשיבותם בימינו. מששמע זאת, הוא שינה את החלטתו, כיוון שעם שנטש את מורשתו רבת השנים הוא עם שבקלות ניתן להביסו. ומן הצד ההפוך, לאחר שנפוליון שב מכיבוש עם נוסף, הוא נדהם לראות שהיהודים בממלכתו נתונים בצער עמוק. הם הסבירו לו שיום זה הוא תשעה באב, והם מתאבלים על חורבן בית המקדש. הוא שאלם מתי היה החורבן, והתשובה הייתה – לפני קרוב לאלפיים שנה. מששמע זאת הוא הכריז – עם ששמר על קשר כה חזק עם מורשתם ועברם – ודאי לא יכחד לעולם! אנו חיים בתקופה בה נסיון היאוש מתבטא בדרגות רבות ושונות. עבור יהודים שאינם שומרי תורה ומצוות, הניסיון הוא ברור – לא לנטוש לחלוטין את מורשת אבותם, ולהיטמע כל כולם בתוך תרבות חילונית. אולם הניסיון שייך לכל אחד בצורה מסוימת. ראשית, אדם עלול להתייאש ממליוני היהודים החילוניים הסובבים אותו, לא להאמין שיש תקווה לאחריתם, בטענה כי הם נטמעו בעולם אחר ואין סיכוי שישובו. ודאי שזוהי גישה שבטעות יסודה, שהרי המציאות הוכיחה שיהודים חילוניים מסוגלים די בקלות יחסית לשוב ולקשור את חייהם ביהדות אמיתית. סוג נוסף של ניסיון קיים, שמירת המצוות אינה בהכרח מונעת את סכנת היאוש. אותם יהודים שאכלו ממשתה אחשוורוש, עדיין הקפידו על כשרות. אדם יכול לשמור על כל המצוות, קלה כבחמורה ועדיין לתהות בליבו האם ייבנה שוב בית המקדש השלישי, ואם באמת יבוא משיח ויגאלנו. יתירה מזאת, היאוש עלול למצא משכן בליבו ולהטרידו בחייו הפרטיים, אדם עלול להשתכנע, חלילה, שאין לו כל סיכוי להגיע לגדלות אמיתית. סיפור המגילה מלמדנו שלעולם אל לנו להתיאש מהתקווה ומהאמונה בטוב המצפה לעם ישראל כולו ולכל אחד ואחד באופן אישי. כל עוד אנו מחזיקים ושומרים על שאיפתנו להיות חלק מעם ה', אנו יכולים לדעת אל בטוח שהוא יגן עלינו מכל אויבינו.

MEGILLA INSIGHTS - PROVIDENCE VERSUS CHANCE

MEGILLA INSIGHTS - PROVIDENCE VERSUS CHANCE One of the recurring themes in the story of Purim is the conflicting ideologies of the Jewish people and Amalek. The Jewish people believe that Divine Providence guides history, nothing is mere ‘coincidence’. In stark contrast, Amalek believe that everything happens by mere chance (mikreh). Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky zt”l brought out a fascinating idea with regard to this ideological clash. He began in Parshas Mikeitz, where Yaakov Avinu refuses to send Binyomin to Mitzrayim. He explained his fear that “perhaps a disaster will happen. Rav Kamenetsky noted that the Hebrew word for ‘happening’ of ‘mikreh’ is spelt here with an ‘aleph’. In Parshas Vayigash, Yehuda recalls the words of Yaakov to the Egyptian Viceroy . “If you also take this one [Biinyomin] from me, a disaster may happen..” On this occasion, the letter ‘aleph’ is omitted from the word, ‘mikreh‘. What is the reason for this change? Rav Kamenetsky explains, that the regular spelling of the word, ‘mikreh’ is without an aleph, and in this form it refers to mere chance. However, when an ‘aleph’ is added, the word ’kara’ (call) is formed. This means that an event is ’called from Heaven’, referring to the fact that there is no coincidence, rather everything takes place because of Divine Providence. With this explanation we can understand the divergence of the spelling of the word, ‘mikreh’. when Yaakov is speaking to Yehuda, he expresses his fear that, if Binyomin would travel to Egypt, Divine Providence may decree that some kind of disaster should befall him. Yaakov was well aware that anything that could happen would not be due to mere chance. When Yehuda was recalling Yaakov’s words he was speaking to Yosef, whom he thought was a non-Jew who was unaware of Divine Providence. Accordingly, he could not express Yaakov’s attitude with regard to Divine Providence because he knew that a non-Jew could not relate to such a concept. Accordingly, he expressed the word, ‘mikreh’ without the ‘aleph’ to refer to mere chance. Dayan Chanoch Erentrau shlita asked Rav Kamenetsky that a passuk from Megillas Esther seemed to contradict the explanation that ‘mikreh’ without an ‘aleph’ refers to an expression of mere chance. After Mordechai became aware of the Decree to destroy the Jewish people he began mourning. Esther sent her messenger, Hasach to find out what had happened. The Megilla writes, “And Mordechai told him about everything that had happened..” In this instance, the word, ‘mikreh’ is written without an ‘aleph’, which alludes to a belief in chance.. According to Rav Kamenetsky’s aforementioned explanation, this should imply that Mordechai was describing the events that had taken place as being a result of mere chance, and not Divine Providence! Rav Kamenetksy answered him that the Medrash dealt with this problem. The Medrash notes the use of the word, ‘mikreh’ and explains that Mordechai was alluding to the fact that the nation that epitomizes the belief in chance, was behind the decree to destroy the Jews. That nation was Amalek, of whom the Torah writes, “who happened (korcha) upon you on the way.” Thus, Mordechai was not attributing the Decree to chance, rather he was telling Esther that the Decree was initiated by a member of the nation of Amalek (Haman), who represent the belief that everything is mere ‘mikreh’ (chance). On a deeper level, it seems that Mordechai was telling Esther that the reason that Amalek were able to threaten the Jews with destruction, was the very same reason that they were able to attack the Jewish people in the desert. The people had expressed their doubts about the presence of HaShem in their midst, when they exclaimed, “is HaShem amongst us or not?!” When the Jewish people attribute events to chance, HaShem measure for measure, allows us to be subject to the rules of chance and ceases protecting us. Therefore, the people’s questioning of Divine Providence enabled Amalek, the ultimate deniers of such Providence, to attack. So too, at the beginning of the Purim story, the Jewish people were far less aware of HaShem’s presence amongst them due to the loss of the Temple and the exile. This decline in belief in Divine Providence gave Haman the ability to threaten them. Only by recognizing that HaShem drives all events, good or bad, could they merit Divine intervention to save them. May we merit to see HaShem’s Hand in everything that takes place around us.