Wednesday, March 5, 2014

ויקרא – קנאה נכונה

כאשר מתארת התורה את הקרבנות השונים ואת הלכותיהם, מובא האיסור להקריב קרבן שאור (חמץ) ודבש . מיד לאחר מכן מובא החיוב להוסיף מלח בכל הקרבנות . מה ההבדל הגדול בין מלח ובין שאור ודבש, עד כדי כך שהוספת מלח היא חובה, בעוד שני האחרים אסורים בתכלית?! המפרשים מצביעים על סמליות רבה הקיימת בעניין הקרבנות, כל אחד משלושה מרכיבים אלו מסמל מידה מסוימת באדם. אם ננתח את המאפיינים של כל אחד מהם, נוכל להשיב על שאלתנו. בעל "ספר החינוך" כותב שדבש מסמל תאווה, כיוון שהוא מאכל מתוק מאד. האיסור להוסיף דבש לקרבנות מלמדנו שאדם צריך להיזהר מהתאווה למאכלים מתוקים, חלף זאת עליו להשתדל לאכל רק את הנחוץ לו למחייתו ולבריאות גופו. ה"חינוך" ממשיך וכותב ששאור מסמל גאווה כיוון שהוא תופח למעלה. ביחס לגאווה הוא מביא את הפסוק במשלי האומר: "תועבת ה' כל גבה לב" . החת"ם סופר זצ"ל ממשיך בדרך פירושו של ה"חינוך" ומפרש מה מסמל המלח. הוא מסתמך על דברי חז"ל המתארים כיצד זכה המלח להיות מוקרב בכל קרבן וקרבן: ביום השני לבריאה הקב"ה הפריד בין המים העליונים למים התחתונים. חלק מהמים הגיעו לשמיים וחלקם השני הגיע לארץ. המים התחתונים טענו לפי ה' שגם הם רוצים לעלות למעלה, למעלה מרוממת וגבוהה יותר של שמים, ולא להישאר בדרגה הנמוכה של הארץ. הקב"ה פייס אותם ואמר להם שעתיד המלח המופק ממימיהם לעלות לגבוה על המזבח יחד עם כל קרבן וקרבן . על בסיס דברי המדרש, מסביר החת"ם סופר שמלח מסמל את מידת הקנאה, כיוון שהוא מוקרב על המזבח כתוצאה מהקנאה שקינאו המים התחתונים במים העליונים. הוא ממשיך וכותב שדבש, שאור ומלח, מסמלים שלושתם שלוש מידות מגונות בסיסיות – קנאה, תאוה וכבוד . אולם, הוא מסביר שהקנאה שונה מאד מהתאווה והכבוד: אין כל מקום לדבש ושאור במשכן, ובהקבלה – אין כל מקום בעבודת ה' לתאווה ולגאווה. לכן ישנו איסור להוסיף בקרבנות דבש ושאור. לעומת זאת הקנאה – יש לה מקום בעבודת ה'. ניתן לראות זאת מדברי הגמרא: "קנאת סופרים תרבה חכמה" – קנאה בינות לתלמידי חכמים גורמת לתוספת חכמה והיא חיובית! . יש תועלת לקנאה בעולם הרוחני כיוון שהיא גורמת לאדם להתקדם ולהתפתח ברוחניות, כאשר הוא רואה אחרים שאוחזים ברמות גבוהות יותר ממנו. קנאתם של המים התחתונים במים העליונים מהווה דוגמא לקנאה חיובית – קנאת סופרים. המים התחתונים השתוקקו לקרבת אלוקים כמו זו שהייתה למים העליונים. ובשכר קנאה זו זכו שהמלח יוקרב בכל קרבן וקרבן. כך הפך המלח המוקרב לתזכורת נצחית עד כמה ראויה לשבח כזו קנאה . הסברו של החת"ם סופר מלמדנו שאם אדם משתמש באופן הנכון ובמקום הנכון במידת הקנאה, למרות שבדרך כלל זוהי מידה מגונה, בכוחה לרומם אותו בעבודת ה'. ננסה לעיין בהבדל הקיים בין קנאה רוחנית, ובין קנאה גשמית. נראה שקיימים שני הבדלים עיקריים: הראשון הוא, המניע לשני סוגי קנאה אלה הוא שונה לחלוטין. קנאה גשמית על פי רוב יש בה היבט מאוס ביותר – אין המקנא רוצה שיהיה לו את אותו חפץ שיש לחברו, אלא המניע בתוך נפשו הוא הרצון שלשני גם כן לא יהיה את אותו החפץ, כשם שאין אותו לו. ואכן, איסור התורה על הקנאה, "לא תחמוד" , קיים רק במצב בו ראובן רוצה את החפץ עצמו שיש לשמעון, לעומת זאת, אם ראובן רוצה לרכוש גם הוא חפץ שיש כמוהו לשמעון – אין בכך שום איסור תורה! לעומת זאת, על פי בעלי המוסר, קנאה נחשבת לרוחנית ורצויה רק כאשר המקנא לא מקנא בהצלחתו הרוחנית של חברו, אלא הוא משתמש באותה הצלחה שרואה בחברו ככלי לסייע ולהניע את עצמו להגיע לדרגות דומות. אולם אם הוא מקנא בהצלחתו האישית של חברו, אזי קנאתו נחשבת לקנאה אסורה כיוון שאין היא נובעת ממניעים טהורים כלל. הבדל נוסף, מביא בעל ה"אבן עזרא" בהסבירו את האיסור של "לא תחמוד". הוא ממשיל זאת לאיש כפרי המשתוקק להינשא לבת המלך. עליו להבין שהיא לא שייכת לתחום ההשגה שלו, ואין לו כל זכות לצפות בכלל לזכות להינשא לה. כך גם כל אדם ואדם מוקצב לו משמים בדיוק מה שמגיע לו בעולם הגשמי, ורק המוקצב לו – זה מה שיגיע לו. כל דבר אחר ששייך לזולת הוא לגמרי מחוץ לתחום ההשגה של האדם, ואין לו כל אפשרות לקבלו גם אם יתאמץ ביותר. לכן כל קנאה בקנייני הזולת היא חסרת טעם ותועלת כיוון שהקב"ה לבדו הוא המספק לכל אחד בדיוק את צרכיו הוא . הסבר זה של האבן עזרא שייך אך ורק בקנאה גשמית, כיוון שכל השתדלות שלא תהא לא תשנה במאומה את המוקצב לאדם - מה שמגיע לו נתון אך ורק בידי ה'. השטח היחיד אותו הקב"ה כביכול נותן בידי האדם הוא העולם הרוחני שלו. ברוחניות אין כל גבול מוחלט עד היכן מסוגל האדם להגיע. נושא זה נתון אך ורק בידי האדם וביד בחירתו החופשית לטוב ולמוטב. ואם כך, ודאי שיש טעם ותהיה תועלת ברצון לדמות לאדם אחר ולהגיע להישגים אליהם הגיע הוא; כיוון שעל ידי מאמצים שישקיע האדם אכן בכוחו להשיג עוד ועוד ולהגיע לדרגות גבוהות יותר ויותר. יש לזכור שתי נקודות עיקריות אלו – בכוח קנאת סופרים להשפיע על האדם ולגרום לו להתרומם ולהתעלות בזכות מעלותיו של חברו, כמובן בלי קנאה אישית בהצלחתו; ונקודה שניה – ראוי ונכון לאדם לנסות ולהשתדל להגיע גבוה יותר ממקומו כרגע. על פי נקודות אלו נקבל הבנה מעמיקה יותר לגבי מקומה של הקנאה בחיינו, ותפקידה בעיצוב עולמנו הרוחני. החת"ם סופר מלמדנו שאמנם בשטחים רבים זוהי מידה שלילית ומגונה מאד, אולם כאשר ישתמש בה האדם באופן הנכון, בכוחה לסייע לו להתעלות ולהתקרב יותר לקב"ה. כך ילמד את הלימוד הנכון מהמים התחתונים ששאיפתם החזקה לזכות ליותר קרבת אלוקים הניבה שכר ופירות.

ויקרא – הקרבה וקִרבה

עניינו העיקרי ביותר של ספר ויקרא הוא סוגי הקרבנות שהוקרבו במשכן, ומאוחר יותר בבית המקדש. חלק מאותם קרבנות נקראים קרבנות נדבה . אין חיוב להקריב קרבנות אלה, אולם אם אדם מתנדב להקריבם, הוא מקיים בכך מצווה ומעשהו נחשב למעשה משובח ונעלה ביותר. הגאון הסטייפלר זצ"ל מעלה שאלה נוקבת במהותם של קרבנות אלה . רוב המצוות הינן חיוביות כלומר, יש חיוב לקיימן, כיוון שבורא עולם בחכמתו חייב בהן כל יהודי ויהודי, וכל אחת מהן מהווה חלק חיוני ובלתי נפרד מכלל עבודת ה'. העובדה שקרבנות נדבה אינם מצוות חיוביות, מעידה לכאורה על כך שהקרבתם אינה חיונית לעבודתו של היהודי... אולם, מצד שני, הקרבת קרבן כזה נחשבת למצווה גדולה, ומכך ניתן להבין שיש להם השפעה כלשהי על האדם, והם בהחלט מיטיבות עם עבודתו הרוחנית. כיצד ניתן להבין את מהותן של מצוות מסוג זה? הסטייפלר עונה על שאלה זו בהבהירו ראשית שאלה חשובה נוספת בהשקפה היהודית. אחת המצוות היסודיות ביותר ביהדות היא מצות אהבת ה'. כל יהודי מחוייב לנתב את רגשותיו כך שתתפתח בליבו אהבה עצומה וללא מצרים לבוראו. כיצד אפשר לצוות על אדם להכיל רגש מסויים – נראה שאין זה בשליטתו של האדם כלל? כתשובה לכך מביא הסטייפלר יסוד מתוך ה"מסילת ישרים" בביאור מידת הזריזות - "כי התנועה החיצונה מעוררת הפנימית" כלומר, בכוחן של פעולות חיצוניות להשפיע על רגשות פנימיים. ולכן אפשר להשיג רגשות רצויים על ידי התנהגות בצורה מסוימת. יסוד זה, כותב הסטייפלר, מתבטא ביותר בהקשר למצוות אהבת ה'. לכל אחד ברור שאהבה פנימית מביאה את האדם להתנהגות המשקפת את אהבתו אל ה', ואת שאיפתו להתעלם מנגיעות ורצונות אישיים ולנהוג אך ורק על פי רצון ה'. כך גם בכיוון השני: התנדבות וקיום מעשים אשר אינם מחויבים, וכל מהותם היא אחת: העמדת רצון ה' בראש סולם העדיפויות, קודם לרצונות האישיים, לבטח מרוממת את האדם וכך קונה הוא בנפשו את מעלת אהבת ה'. על פי יסוד זה, מסביר הסטייפלר את מהותם של קרבנות הנדבה. בקרבנות אלה טמונה הזדמנות פז לאדם – להגיע לקרבת אלוקים על ידי ביטול רצון האדם מפני רצון ה': האדם מוותר על עניינים אנוכיים הקשורים אליו, הוא משקיע מאמץ וזמן לא מבוטל, מפריש סכום נכבד מכספו ומגיע לבית המקדש כשבהמה, עוף או מנחה בידו – הכל במטרה להקריב קרבן לה'. ביטול כזה של רצונות אישיים למען רצון ה' רב כוחו וגדולה סגולתו להביא את האדם לרמה גבוהה מאד של אהבת ה'. כך מובן מדוע קרבנות נדבה נחשבים למצווה כה יקרה ומשובחת. אם הייתה התורה מחייבת כל יהודי להביא קרבנות כאלה, הרי היה ניטל מהם כל עניינים ומטרתם – כאשר אדם מחויב להקריב משלו לאחר, לא מתפתחים בליבו רגשי אהבה כפי שמתפתחים בעת שאדם מתנדב מעצמו, רגשותיו מסתכמים בתחושת מילוי חובה בעלמא ולא הרבה מעבר לכך. לכן, העניקה התורה לכל יהודי הזדמנות לעשות מעשה שלבטח יעלה וירומם את דרגת אהבת ה' שבלבו, וקבעה כי קרבנות נדבה אינם חובה אלא זכות. עם כל זאת, הקרבת קרבנות כאלה נחשבת למצווה גדולה בשל השפעתה החזקה על האדם ועל אהבתו לבוראו. יסוד זה, כותב הסטייפלר, אינו קשור אך ורק לעניין הקרבנות; אדם יכול לבחור כל נושא שהוא, בו הוא רוצה להשקיע מאמצים גדולים יותר, מעבר לנדרש ממנו בשורת הדין. אם יקריב האדם משלו, מתוך רצון והתנדבות אישית – יגיע הוא על ידי כך לעליה והתרוממות באהבת ה'. רעיון זה מתבטא יפה בסיפור הבא, שסופר על ידי ר' יששכר פריינד שליט"א: פעם אחת הוא נסע בטרמפ ברכבו של אדם שהיה נראה יהודי פשוט. מתוך השיחה שהתגלגלה ביניהם התברר שאותו יהודי שם דגש מיוחד על מצות התפילה. במשך השנים האחרונות הוא לא הפסיד אף תפילה אחת במניין, הוא אף ביטל פעם מקום בו היה אמור לנפוש כאשר התברר לו שלא יוכל למצוא באזור מנין לתפילה. מעבר לכך, הוא מעולם לא התפלל תפילת מנחה או מעריב בזמן שהוא לא לכתחילה. אדם זה בחר לעצמו נושא אחד אשר בו הוא משקיע מאמצים מיוחדים, ולמענו הוא מקריב רבות מעצמו. בשל הנהגתו זו הוא ודאי זוכה לעליה והתרוממות באהבת ה'. הוא לא עושה את מעשיו רק בגלל שהוא חייב, שהרי בקלות ניתן למצוא היתרים במקרים מסוימים להפסיד תפילה במניין, או להתפלל בזמן של "דיעבד". אולם הוא בחר אחרת: זו היא דרכו לבטא את שאיפתו הטהורה לקיים את רצון ה', לכן הוא נזהר ביתר זהירות, אף מעבר לדרישות ההלכה המינימליות במצות התפילה. מדברי הסטייפלר אנו לומדים שהדרך היחידה בה יכול האדם לקנות בנפשו רגשי קרבה לבוראו היא על ידי עשיית פעולות שהן בגדר התנדבות, ואינן חיוב. התורה לא מצווה עליהן במפורש אבל קיומן נחשב למעשה משובח ביותר. כל אדם יתעלה ויתרומם אם רק ישתדל למצוא לעצמו לפחות שטח אחד בו ישקיע את מירב המאמצים ויקיים בגופו פעולות אשר תגרומנה לליבו ולנשמתו להתקרב עוד ועוד לבוראו.

PURIM - KEEPING HOPE

The Gemara tells us that the terrible decree to destroy the Jewish people was a punishment for their partaking of the banquet of Achashveirosh . Throughout the period of the first Beis HaMikdash, the Prophets were rebuking the Jewish people for terrible sins, including Avoda Zara, and yet they were never sentenced to universal destruction - why was such a drastic punishment reserved for the seemingly mild aveiro of eating at Achashveirosh’s banquet? In order to answer this question let us first discuss the intentions of Achashveirosh in throwing such a lavish banquet. Chazal tell us that the drinks were served in the keilim that were used in the Avoda in the Beis HaMikdash. The King even dressed himself in the clothes of the Kohen Gadol - what was he trying to achieve by doing this? Rav Chaim Halpern Shlita explains that up till this point in time, Achashveirosh had been worried about the prophecy of Yeremyahu that the Jewish people would return to Eretz Yisroel and rebuild the Beis HaMikdash after 70 years. The King calculated that the 70 years had now passed without any sign of the prophecy being fulfilled. Consequently, on the exact day that he had calculated that the time was up he held the feast - he was trying to tell the Jews that they should give up hope of the Beis HaMikdash and that they now had an alternative source of happiness - his Kingdom. Therefore, he dressed up as the Kohen Gadol to show that he was their new leader, and he gave them the Temple vessels to show them that there was no point in waiting any longer for the Beis HaMikdash to be rebuilt . Unfortunately, the Jewish people accepted the King’s message and willfully joined in the Seuda, even drinking from the Temple vessels. They gave up hope - they terminated their desire for a Second Beis HaMikdash, and turned to a new future, being loyal subjects of the King and his Empire. What in effect they had done was give up on the unique role of the Jewish people as the Chosen People who were meant to serve as a Light Unto the Nations. They forsook any hope of a return to Eretz Yisroel and a new Beis HaMikdash. What they did not realize is that the Jewish people’s whole right to existence is based on their unique role in the world. Hashem cherishes the Jewish people because of its willingness to serve as an Am Segula who teaches the world to know Him. Now that they did not want to assume this unique role they automatically forsook any right to exist. Measure for measure, they were sentenced to destruction . How did the Jewish people overturn the decree of destruction? The Gemara tells us the conversation that took place when Haman came to inform Mordechai of the honor that the King wanted to bestow on him. Haman found Mordechai learning Torah: Haman asked, “What are you learning?” Mordechai answered, “When the Beis HaMikdash existed, a person who gave a Mincha offering would bring a handful of flour and it would atone for him.” Upon hearing this, Haman replied, “your handful of flour will come and overturn my ten thousand silver shekalim. ” This Gemara is very difficult to understand - what was the significance of what Mordechai was learning and why did it make Haman realize that he would be defeated? The Ponevezher Rav explains that Haman knew that his hope of success lay in the defeatism that the Jewish people expressed at the Seudas Achashveirosh. He saw that Mordechai was teaching about laws that only apply when the Beis HaMikdash is standing - he realized that the Jewish people had done teshuva and reignited their desire for a new Beis HaMikdash. They still had hope that they could continue in their unique role as the Light Unto Nations, and consequently Haman knew that if they had not given up on Hashem then He would not give up on them. The nisayon of the Jews in the time of Purim was to maintain hope during trying times. This nisayon continues to this very day and when we demonstrate weakness in it, our enemies gain encouragement that they can defeat us. The story is told of an infamous Arab terrorist who discussed the time he spent in an Israeli prison, after which he resumed his evil activities with even greater zeal. He said that, whilst in prison, he had initially decided to renounce his ‘career’ as a terrorist, feeling that his violent actions could not succeed in destroying Israel. However, one Pesach, he saw an Israeli guard eating a pitta. Knowing about the issur of eating chametz he inquired as to why the Jew was not observing this law. The Guard answered him that these laws are no longer of any importance. Hearing this, he decided that a people who had given up on their heritage could indeed be defeated. In stark contrast, after Napoleon had conquered yet another nation, he was shocked to see that the Jews were in grief. They explained to him that it was Tisha B’Av and they were mourning the destruction of the Temples. He asked them when this occurred and they explained that it was nearly 2000 years earlier. Upon hearing this he exclaimed that a people who kept such a strong connection to their heritage would surely never be destroyed. We live in a time where the test of yeush exists on many different levels. For non-observant Jews, the test is obvious - not to completely abandon their heritage by assimilating into secular culture. But the nisayon applies to everyone in some form: Firstly, one may be tempted to give up on the millions of secular Jews, arguing that they are irretrievably lost to assimilation. This is of course a highly erroneous attitude and experience has proven that secular Jews can be quite easily reconnected to genuine Judaism. A second nisayon is that keeping the mitzvos does not necessarily preclude yeush - indeed the Jews who ate at the King’s banquet were still makpid only to eat kosher food. A person can keep mitzvos and still wonder if there will ever be a Third Beis Hamikdash and if Mashiach will really come. Moreover, yeush can plague our personal lives, persuading us that we have no possibility of achieving greatness. The story of Purim teaches us that we need never give up hope, both for the Jewish nation and ourselves as individuals - and as long as we maintain our desire to be the part of the Am Hashema we can be assured that He will protect us from all of our enemies.

VAYIKRA - GIFT OFFERINGS

The Book of Vayikra focuses to a significant degree on the various korbanos that were to be given in the Mishkan (Tabernacle), and later the Beis HaMikdash (Temple). A number of these korbanos are known as korbanos nedava (gift offerings). They are not obligatory, yet if a person is aroused to give such an offering, then he fulfils a Mitzo and to do so is considered highly praiseworthy. The Steipler Gaon zt"l asks a penetrating question about the nature of these korbanos nedava . Most Mitzvos are obligatory because HaShem's wisdom decreed that a Jew must fulfill them, thus they are an essential aspect of one's Avodas Hashem. Korbanos Nedava are not obligatory, implying that they are not essential to a Jew's Avoda.. However, on the other hand, offering such korbanos is considered to be a Mitza, implying that there is some kind of benefit in their offering and that they do have a place in one's Avoda. How can we understand the nature of this kind of Mitzva? The Steipler answers this by first addressing another important question in Jewish thought. One of the most fundamental Mitzvos is that of Ahavas HaShem (to love Hashem). This obligates a Jew to direct his emotions in such a way that he develops a strong love of HaShem. How can the Torah can obligate one to have a particular emotion - surely that is beyond a person's control? To answer this problem, the Steipler brings the yesod (principle) of the Mesillas Yesharim (Path of the Just), with regards to the trait of zerizus (zealousness) . He writes that just as internal inspiration brings about external actions, so too, external actions can arouse one's inner feelings. Thus, acting in a certain manner can bring about desired emotions. The Steipler writes that this yesod applies very strongly to the Mitzva of Ahavas Hashem. We know that an internal love brings one to actions reflecting his love for HaShem and his willingness to ignore his own desires for the sake of HaShem's honor. So too, performing voluntary actions that involve placing HaShem's Ratson (will) before one's own desires, will bring a person to an increased love of HaShem. With this yesod, the Steipler explains the nature of korbanos nedava. These korbanos provide a person with a great opportunity to get close to HaShem by placing Him before the person: He forgoes his own needs by exerting a considerable amount of time, effort and money, in order to bring an animal or food offering to the Temple and offer it up to HaShem. Showing such selflessness on behalf of HaShem is a highly effective way of arousing one's love of Him. This explains why bringing korbanos nedava is such a praiseworthy act. However, if the Torah obligated every Jew to bring such korbanos, then their whole purpose would be lost - when one is obligated to give of himself to another, he does not develop feelings of love, rather he feels that he is paying a debt that he owes. Thus, the Torah gives each Jew the opportunity to arouse himself to fulfill an action that will surely increase his ahavas HaShem by making korbanos nedava 'optional'. Yet at the same time, offering such korbanos is considered a great Mitzva because of its effectiveness in bringing about love of Hashem. The Steipler writes that this yesod is not limited to korbanos; a person can choose any specific area where he desires to exert an extra amount of effort that goes beyond what is required by law. By 'willingly' giving of himself in one area he can bring himself to an increased love of HaShem. This idea is demonstrated by the following story told over by Rav Yissachar Frand Shlita: He was once given a ride by a seemingly ordinary Jew. In the course of the conversation it emerged that this Jew gave particular emphasis to the Mitzvo of prayer. He had not missed praying in a minyan for several years and even cancelled a vacation to a place when he realized that he would be unable to find a minyan there. Further, he never prayed Mincha or Maariv before or after the ideal time. This man chose one area in which to put in that extra effort and self-sacrifice and in this way he was surely able to arouse in himself an increased love for HaShem. He didn't need to feel obligated to act in this way because it is possible to find heterim (leniencies) to sometimes miss a minyan and not pray in the ideal zman. Yet he chose to express his desire to do Ratson Hashem by being extra careful in the Mitzva of prayer. We learn from the yesod of the Steipler, that a key method of bringing oneself closer to HaShem is by doing actions that are not considered obligatory according to the Torah but that are certainly praiseworthy. It is instructive for each person to strive to find at least one area in which he makes that extra exertion in his efforts to get closer to HaShem.

MEGILLA – RASHI INSIGHTS

Megilla Esther, 1:1: “And it was in the days of Achashverosh: he is Achashverosh who ruled from Hodu to Cush over a hundred and twenty seven provinces.” Rashi, 1:1: sv. He is Achashverosh: He [remained] in his evil from the beginning until the end. In the first verse in the Megilla, Rashi reveals an allusion to the nature of King Achashverosh, one of the main characters in the story. He teaches us that Achashverosh was an evil person at the beginning of the story and remained evil till the very end. Two questions arise: Firstly, every detail in the Megilla teaches us a message that is connected to the theme of Purim – in what way is the fact that Achashverosh remained evil relevant to the lessons of Purim? Secondly, why, of all the many reshaim who feature in the Tanach is Achashverosh one of the only ones to be singled out for this particular criticism? By answering the second question we can then understand the first as well. It seems that there are two very significant factors that can cause a wayward person to change his ways; the first is exposure to righteous people. The Torah instructs us to cleave to talmidei chachamim and Chazal speak at length of the importance of spending as much time as possible with great people because one can learn from their righteous behavior and see first-hand the results of living a spiritual life. A second possible catalyst for teshuva is the events surrounding us; when a person is involved in events that seem to be guided by the Divine Hand, he has the opportunity to respond to the Divine message and change his ways. Achashverosh merited both opportunities; He married the righteous Esther, whose greatness could not have been hidden from him despite her secretive nature. Moreover, his main advisor towards the end of his life was Mordechai HaTzadik, one of the greatest Sages of the time. Achashverosh also had the good fortune to be one of the players in the remarkable Purim story - the account of how the very existence of the Jewish people was threatened, and yet everything was miraculously turned on its head. It would be difficult to not be positively affected by such great people and by being part of such a miraculous story. Yet Achashverosh remained the same, greedy, selfish person at the end of the story and indeed the end of his life. One proof of this is mentioned by the Gemara is found in one of the very last verses in the Megilla: “And King Achashverosh placed a tax on the land and the islands.” The commentaries explain that when he married Esther he reduced the taxes on his Kingdom so that her home nation might reveal itself to him in order to benefit further from its new connection to the King. At the end of the story he knew her identity, therefore he raised the taxes again. This demonstrates that at the climax of the Purim story all Achashverosh could think about was money. Another indication that he remained evil is that he never committed to rebuilding the second Temple despite the great benefits he derived from Mordechai and Esther. We can now understand the connection between Achashverosh’s flaw and the Purim story. The lesson of Purim is to see the Divine Providence even in a time of Hester Panim (when HaShem’s Presence is hidden) and to increase our awareness of HaShem in our own lives. Yet it is insufficient if that newfound recognition remains in the realm of the mind and heart. It must bring about an enhancement in one’s Avodas HaShem. The example of Achashverosh teaches us how not to respond to Divine Providence – remaining oblivious to HaShem’s messages and engulfed in base lusts and desires.

Monday, March 3, 2014

VAYIKRA - THE RIGHT KIND OF JEALOUSY

During its outline of the various korbanos (sacrifices), the Torah forbids bringing offerings of leaven and honey . It then immediately tells us that, in contrast, we must include salt in all the meal-offerings. What is the difference between salt with honey and leaven, to the extent that salt is obligatory, whilst the other two substances are forbidden?! The commentaries point out that there is great symbolism in the korbanos, and that each of these three substances represent various character traits – by analyzing their symbolism we can answer this question. The Sefer HaChinuch writes that honey represents base physical desire (taiva) because it is a sweet tasting food. The prohibition from adding honey to the offerings teaches us that one should refrain from chasing after sweet tasting foods, and should focus only on eating food that is necessary for his sustenance and well-being. The Chinuch continues that leaven is symbolic of arrogance because it rises up. With regard to arrogance, he brings the verse in Mishlei that states: “The haughty of heart is an abomination to HaShem.” The Chasam Sofer zt”l continues in the same vein as the Chinuch with regard to honey and leaven. He then discusses the symbolism of salt. He alludes to the well-known maamer Chazal (saying of the Sages) that provides the background behind the obligation to include salt with the meal offerings. On the second day of Creation, HaShem separated the waters into two, bringing part of the water up to Shamayim and leaving part on the Earth. The lower waters complained that they also wanted to go up to the exalted Heavens rather than remain on the lowly Earth. HaShem appeased them by telling them that in the future the salt that is found in the water would, in the future, be offered up on the Altar along with the korbanos. Based on this Midrash, the Chasam Sofer explains that salt represents the trait of jealousy because it is offered as a result of the jealousy of the lower waters towards the upper waters. He continues that honey, leaven, and salt represent the three basic negative traits; kina (jealousy), kavod (desire for honor) and taiva. However, he argues that jealousy is very different from the other two: There is no place for them in the Mishkan, and, by extension, in all Avodas HaShem (Divine Service), Therefore, there is no place for honey and leaven with the korbanos. He writes that jealousy, in contrast, does have a place in Avodas HaShem. We see this from the Gemara that says, ‘kinas sofrim tarbeh chachma’ – jealousy amongst those learning causes an increase in wisdom. This means that there is a benefit to jealousy in the spiritual realm because it can motivate a person to grow in his spirituality when he sees others performing on a higher level than himself. In this vein he explains that the jealousy of the lower waters for the upper waters was an example of a valid type of jealousy – the lower waters wanted to be as close to HaShem as the upper waters. Their reward was the salt that would be offered up. Accordingly, this salt remains as an eternal reminder of the praiseworthy form of jealousy. The Chasam Sofer’s explanation teaches us that when the generally negative trait of jealousy is used in the right way, it can enhance one’s Avodas HaShem. It is instructive to analyze the difference between jealousy in the spiritual realm and jealousy in the physical realm. It seems that there are two main differences: Firstly, the motivation of the two types of jealousy varies greatly. Jealousy in the material realm often has a particularly abhorrent aspect – it is not limited to wanting the same things the other person, rather the jealous person wants that the other person to not have that thing as well. Indeed, the Torah prohibition that relates to jealousy, loh sachmod (do not covet), only applies when Reuven wants to have Shimon’s item itself, whereas if he only wants the same item as Shimon, there is no Torah prohibition. In contrast, the Baalei Mussar point out that jealousy in the spiritual realm is only acceptable when the jealous party does not begrudge his fellow of his success, rather he uses his friend’s success as a tool to help motivate himself to achieve similar heights. However, if he begrudges his friend his success then his jealousy is again considered totally unacceptable because it is clearly not driven by pure motivations. The second difference is brought out by the Ibn Ezra’s explanation of the Mitzvo of loh sachmod. He offers an analogy of a peasant who desires to marry a princess. The peasant should realize that she is simply not in his domain, and that he has no right to expect to gain her hand in marriage. So too, each person is allotted exactly what they need in the material world. Anything that someone else owns is totally irrelevant to them and outside of their domain. They have no reason to desire it, because HaShem provides each person with exactly what they need. The reasoning of the Ibn Ezra only applies to jealousy in the material realm, because no amount of hishtadlus (effort) will alter a person’s possessions – that is completely in HaShem’s Hands. The one area in which HaShem stands back, so-to-speak, is spirituality. In the spiritual realm there is no predestined limit to what a person can achieve. It is completely dependent upon his own free will. Accordingly, it is not fruitless to desire to emulate someone else’s spiritual achievement; through personal effort, a person can attain more in ruchnius. Bearing these two points in mind – that kinas sofrim induces a person to emulate his fellow without begrudging him his own success; and that one has the right to try to attain more than he presently has – we now have a deeper understanding of the role of jealousy in our lives. The Chasam Sofer teaches us that, whilst in many circumstances, it is a negative trait, when utilized in the right way, it can help us grow closer to HaShem, and in that way emulate the lower waters whose burning desire to get close to HaShem bore fruits.

VAYIKRA – INSIGHTS IN RASHI – EFFORT VERSUS RESULTS

Vayikra, 2:1: “When a soul (nefesh) offers a meal-offering to HaShem, his offering shall be of fine flour; he shall pour oil upon it and place frankincense upon it.” Rashi, Vayikra, 2:1: sv. When a soul offers: “It does not say ‘nefesh’ with regards to any of the gift offerings except the meal offering; for who is it normal to offer a meal offering? A poor person; HaShem says, I consider it as if he offered his soul.” Rashi, based on the Gemara , explains the unusual usage of the word, ‘nefesh’ that means soul. It teaches us that even though the poor man gives a simple korban (offering) God ascribes great value to it since a great amount of self-sacrifice was invested by him in order to be able to bring even this humble offering. The Midrash tells a number of stories to demonstrate this point. One of them involves King Agrippas who wanted to offer 1000 birds on one day; he instructed the Kohen Gadol not to allow anyone else to bring an offering on that day yet one poor man came with two doves to offer. The Kohen Gadol told him that he could not do so because of the King’s instructions. The man replied that every day he caught four doves and he offered two of them and made his livelihood from the other two – he had a strong Emuna that it was the merit of his daily offering that enabled him to make his livelihood. Accordingly he argued that he would lose his livelihood if he was unable to bring this offering. The Kohen Gadol was could not refuse his supplications and accepted his offering. That night Aggripas was told in a dream that the poor man’s simple offering was considered greater than his thousand. One of the important lessons that we learn from here is that HaShem is more interested in the process that led to a Mitzva than the actual resultant Mitzva. The effort that a person makes is far more significant than the results he achieves. This idea has a number of applications in life; one very important application is in the realm of chinuch (child development). A number of Torah based mechanchim stress that is recommended to praise effort as opposed to natural ability. The Midrash here teaches us that a fundamental reason for this is that natural ability that leads to good results does not make a person worthy of praise since that is a G-d given gift, whereas effort is deserving of praise because one does have free will as to how much effort the exerts. A number of studies in the academic world show how there are also a number of practical benefits to praising one’s efforts over his achievements. Researchers found that children reacted very differently depending on the kinds of praise they received. One surprising result was that praising innate ability could actually later lead to feelings of inadequacy: In one study children were given moderately difficult problems to solve. When each child was finished, he was told, “Wow, you did really well on these problems. You got a really high score.” In addition, each kid received one of three treatments. He was either praised for his intelligence (“you must be smart at these problems”), praised for his effort (“you must have worked hard at these problems”) or not given any additional praise (this was the control group). Then the children were given a second set of problems which were very difficult. They were asked to explain why they performed poorly. The children who had been praised for their intelligence on previous tasks attributed more of their failure to a lack of intelligence. Whereas those initially praised for their effort (and those who were not additionally praised) attributed their failure to a lack of effort. In this way, we see that praising one’s ability had a negative effect – even though initially it could make the recipient feel good about itself, it ultimately ‘sets him up for a fall’ in that when the inevitable failure takes place, his self-image is damaged. In contrast, one who is praised for effort does not feel unworthy when he fails, rather he sees that he needs to work harder in the future. These and similar studies revealed other important lessons: children who were praised for their intelligence tended to avoid challenges because by undertaking them they were liable to feeling inadequate were they to fail. And when they did fail, they were more likely to perform poorly after that failure. They were also more interested in being better than other children rather than trying to better themselves. And finally, they were more prone to cheating or lying in order to attain better grades in order to justify their reputation of being naturally intelligent. In contrast, the children praised for their effort displayed the opposite trend. They preferred tasks that were challenging so that they could improve themselves; and failure did not have such a damaging effect on their future performance. We have seen that the humble Mincha offering of the poor person is of great value in God’s eyes because of the effort involved, and how in general, stress on effort is far more successful in helping educate children and students, May we all merit to learn and integrate these vital lessons.