Monday, March 4, 2013
ויקהל- הגשמת הפוטנציאל שלנו
בעת שמתארת התורה את בניית המשכן, נאמר: "ויבאו כל איש אשר נשאו ליבו…" . הרמב"ן כותב שמילים אלה נאמרו על אלה שהתנדבו לעבודות כגון אריגה, תפירה ובנייה. היכן ומתי התיימנו אותם אנשים באומנויות אלה? עונה הרמב"ן שהם גילו בתוך תוכם את הידע והיכולת לעשות זאת. אותם כוחות שהיו עד כה טמונים עמוק, באו לידי ביטוי בזכות שאיפתם החזקה למלא את רצון ה' ולסייע בבניית המשכן. הקב"ה ראה את רצונם העז לעשות רצונו, ולכן נתן בידם את היכולת לבצע מלאכות אשר מעולם לא למדו לעשותן.
מקובל לחשוב, שכל אחד מאיתנו מקבל מאת ה' כעין "חבילה" של כוחות וכשרונות אשר באמצעותם יוכל למלא את הפוטנציאל הגלום בו. עד כמה שרעיון זה נכון בהחלט, ייתכן ואין זה מדויק לגמרי: כאשר אדם גדל ומתבגר, לאט לאט הוא נעשה מודע יותר ויותר לכוחותיו ומאידך – לחולשותיו. נטייתנו הטבעית היא לגדור את עצמנו ואת מעשינו לשטחים בהם אנו יודעים שהם נקודות החוזק שלנו, ולהתעלם משטחים אחרים בהם אנו חלשים יותר. לדוגמא, אדם יכול לשים לב שהוא מצליח מאד בעת שמדבר לפני קהל מצומצם של אנשים, לעומת זאת הוא אינו מסוגל לדבר בפני קהל גדול. לכן גם כאשר יווצר מצב בו זקוקים לאדם שידבר בפני אנשים רבים, הוא יתחמק ממשימה כזו ולא ייקח על עצמו את האחריות, כיוון שברור ומוחלט לו שהוא אינו מסוגל לדבר בפני קהל גדול. לומדים מדברי הרמב"ן שגישה זו שגויה מעיקרה – האנשים שהתנדבו לעבודה במשכן לא היו מודעים כלל לכך שיש בהם את היכולת לעבוד עבודות אומנותיות כאלה – אולם, כיוון שהם הקדישו את עצמם לעבודת ה', הם מצאו בעצמם כישרונות חבויים שעד כה לא נוצלו כלל, וכעת נוצלו לשם מילוי רצון ה'. באותה מידה, בחיינו אנו, פעמים מגיעים מצבים בהם יש צורך באדם שיבצע משימה מסוימת, במבט ראשון אדם עלול לחשוב שהוא אינו מסוגל לכך, אבל, אומרת המשנה באבות "במקום שאין אנשים השתדל להיות איש", המשנה לא כתבה כל הסתייגות בהוראה זו, ולא אמרה שעל האדם להיות איש רק במצבים בהם נראה לו שהוא המתאים לתפקיד. אלא הקריטריון היחיד לחיובו של האדם לקום ולפעול הוא שאין מלבדו שום אדם אחר שיכול לעשות זאת. ובמצב כזה, אם אכן האדם מקדיש את עצמו רק למען עשיית רצון ה', וודאי ה' עוזר לו ומוציא אל הפועל כוחות וכשרונות אשר היו חבויים בתוכו.
ישנן דוגמאות רבות לבני אדם שהוציאו אל הפועל כוחות שהיו גלומים בהם, וכתוצאה מכך זכו והגיעו להישגים מדהימים; אחת הדוגמאות המיוחדות ביותר היא זו של הנצי"ב זצ"ל. כאשר הנצי"ב השלים את פירושו "העמק שאלה" על השאילתות הוא הכין סעודה, כנהוג כאשר אדם מסיים לכתוב ספר, אולם מלבד סיבה פשוטה זו, היתה לנצי"ב גם סיבה אישית נוספת, ובמעמד הסעודה קם וסיפר לנוכחים את סיפורו: בילדותו התייחס בזלזול רב ללימודים ב"חדר", הוריו עשו כל מאמץ לעזור לו לשנות את יחסו ללימודים, אך ללא הועיל. יום אחד, הוא הקשיב להוריו ששוחחו אודותיו, ואודות כשלונו בלימודיו – והגיעו להחלטה שאין לו שום סיכוי להיות בעתיד תלמיד חכם, ועל כן מוטב שילמד להיות סנדלר. אם תלמיד חכם כשאיפתם – לא יהיה, לפחות יהודי טוב יהיה, ירא שמים, שיעשה את עבודתו בהגינות ובאמונה. כך החליטו. החלטה זו, של הוריו זעזעה את נפתלי צבי הקטן עד עמקי נשמתו, והוא החליט לשנס מותניו ולהתחיל ללמוד ברצינות. מאורע זה השפיע בעצמה כה חזקה על חייו, עד שמיום זה והלאה חל שינוי מוחלט בכל הנהגתו ויחסו לתורה, והוא הפך בסופו של דבר לגדול בישראל. מה היה הכוח בזכותו זכה למה שזכה - הרצון העז שנבט בליבו לגדול בתורה – הוא זה שגילה בתוכו כוחות עצומים שהיו חבויים עד כה, וכאשר השתמש בהם, הגיע על ידם לפסגות.
אדם עלול לטעון בשמעו סיפור כזה שלא כל אחד מסוגל להיות תלמיד חכם גדול כל כך. אולם, ההיסטוריה היהודית מוכיחה שאדם לא מוכרח להיות דווקא גדול בישראל כדי לתרום תרומות חשובות עבור כלל ישראל – לפעמים ישנם שטחים אחרים בהם אדם יכול להצטיין ולמלא בכך את רצון ה'. ר' דוד דריאן זצ"ל מהווה דוגמא מצוינת לכך: הוא היה שוחט צדיק, אשר היה ידוע בשמירת הלשון המיוחדת שלו, אולם דמותו הייתה בולטת הודות לסיבה אחרת: הוא שימש תפקיד משמעותי ביותר בכל המערכת של כולל גיטסהד וסמינר גיטסהד. הודות לעבודתו המסורה "גיטסהד" ידועה היום כמרכז התורה הגדול ביותר באירופה, בו מתחנכים אלפי בחורים ובחורות לתורה ויראת שמים ברמה גבוהה. כיצד זכה ר' דוד דריאן בכזו זכות? כאשר הוא הגיע לגור בגיטסהד, הוא ראה שאין במקום שום ישיבה. הוא אמר לעצמו – איך אוכל לגור במקום כזה, אשר אין בו אף ישיבה אחת? רבים מאיתנו היו שואלים גם הם שאלה כזו לו היו עומדים במצב דומה, ההבדל היחיד הוא שר' דוד לא רק שאל, אלא גם עשה. משימה זו הייתה נראית כבלתי אפשרית בעליל למול כל ההפרעות וההתנגדויות מסביב, אולם הוא הקדיש זמן רב ומאמצים בלתי נדלים. הוא פעל ללא לאות - ואכן, חפץ ה' הצליח בידו. הוא לקח על עצמו משימות רבות – לאו דווקא כאלה שהיו נראות מתאימות לו ותואמות את כישוריו, כגון התרמה, וניהול. הוא היה יכול בקלות לטעון שתפקידו הוא שוחט, ובזה מסתכמת אחריותו למען הקהילה. אולם חלף זאת הוא שאב מעצמו כוחות בלתי נדלים על מנת לעשות את הנצרך, וה' העניק לו את הכוחות להצליח.
גם למול סיפורים מפעימי רוח אלה, עדיין עלול אדם לטעון שהוא כן השקיע בעבר מאמצים רבים בשטח מסוים – ולא עלתה בידו, לכן הוא פוטר את עצמו מכל אחריות בעניין זה. ה"חפץ חיים" זצ"ל עונה בדבריו לטענה כזו, ואומר - כמה מאמצים משקיעים אנו בנושאים המעניינים אותנו וחשובים לנו. לדוגמא, אדם שלא מצליח בעסקו, הוא לא מרים ידיים כל כך מהר, אלא הוא משקיע מחשבה ללא הרף כיצד לשפר את המצב – הוא הולך לבקש עצה ממביני דבר, ובסופו של דבר בדרך כלל הוא גם מצליח. כך גם, כותב ה"חפץ חיים", אם רצון ה' היה תופס מקום משמעותי בחיי האדם כמו רצונותיו האישיים, הוא היה תר ומחפש אחר עצות, רעיונות, דרכים ותחבולות כיצד להגדיל תורה ולהאדירה – ובודאי הקב"ה היה עוזר לו ומראה לו את הדרך להצליח, אולם לא כך אנו נוהגים בענייני רוחניות. ברגע שאדם רואה שהוא לא מצליח לקדם ולשפר את המצב – הוא מיד מתיאש ופוטר את עצמו מכל אחריות לפעול בעניין. לו היינו מוכנים להפעיל לצורך עבודת ה' את אותם מאמצים אותם אנו משקיעים למען צרכינו האישיים או למען צרכי פרנסתנו – ודאי היינו מצליחים להתעלות הרבה מעבר לגבולות המקובלים.
גם בימינו אנו, ישנה דוגמא חיה יוצאת מגדר הרגיל לאדם שמגלם בחייו את דברי ה"חפץ חיים". ר' מאיר שוסטר שליט"א הוא אדם ביישן בטבעו, המוצא את כל אושרו בעת שיושב בבית המדרש ללימוד או לתפילה. לפני שנים רבות הוא הבחין בצורך מסוים בעולם היהודי: מידי יום מבקרים בכותל המערבי עשרות יהודים שאינם שומרי תורה ומצוות, ושבים מהביקור להמשך חיים ריקנים מכל תוכן יהודי. הוא מצא לנכון כי חובה היא לפנות אל אותם אנשים ולהציע להם להתארח באכסניה, ושם לשכנע ולעודד את המתארחים ללכת ללמוד בישיבה או בסמינר. הוא החליט לקחת משימה זו על עצמו. משימה זו דרשה ממנו ללכת נגד טבעו הביישן, לגשת לאנשים זרים ולפתוח עמם בשיחה. לאחר שנים של עשייה כזו, אי אפשר לאמוד כמה מאות יהודים שינו את חייהם הודות להחלטתו האמיצה לפעול נגד אופיו הטבעי – ולמלא את רצון ה'. אולם ברור שאם הוא היה מתגדר בתוך עצמו, ומגביל את עשייתו הרוחנית אך ורק למה שאופיו וכשרונותיו מניחים לו לעשות – הרי כל העולם היהודי היה מפסיד מכך המון. האנשים אשר נשאם ליבם והחליטו למלא את רצון ה', גילו בעצמם כוחות שמעולם לא דמיינו שהם קיימים. גם לנו, לכל אחד ואחד יש כוח ויכולת לפרוץ את הגבולות הטבעיים שלנו ולהגיע אל מה שנראה כבלתי אפשרי.
פקודי - מאמץ רוחני
לאחר שמלאכת בניית המשכן הגיעה אל סיומה, לא הצליחו העוסקים במלאכה להעמידו מחמת כובד הקרשים. כיוון שלמשה רבנו לא היה חלק בעבודות המשכן, רצה הקב"ה להעניק לו כבוד זה של העמדת המשכן על מכונו. לכן, הורה לו הקב"ה לנסות לעשות זאת – והמשכן מעצמו יזקף ויעמוד, וכך יראה כלפי חוץ כאילו עשה זאת משה רבנו בעצמו .
במעשה זה ישנו קושי מסוים – זכות העמדת המשכן ניתנה למשה רבנו, ועם זאת, למעשה הוא לא פעל כלום – הקב"ה, הוא זה שהעמיד את המשכן בכבודו ובעצמו! כיצד אפשר להבין זאת? האמת היא, שכל מצווה שיש ביכלתנו לקיים זה רק כיוון שהקב"ה העניק לנו את היכולת לקיימה – הוא בכל רגע ורגע משפיע כוח וחידוש לעולמו, ולכל אדם ואדם בו – לולא השפעה מתמדת זו משמיים, לא היינו יכולים לעשות דבר! השוני היחיד הקיים בין כל מצווה אחרת ובין מעשה הקמת המשכן הוא שזהו נס גלוי, בעוד הכוח לקיים מצוות אחרות הוא נס נסתר. השכר שאנו מקבלים על מעשינו, אינו על תוצאת המעשה – אלא על המאמץ וההשקעה שהשקענו בו. משה רבנו השקיע את המאמצים על מנת להעמיד את המשכן, ולכן נחשבת לו הזכות כאילו באמת עשה זאת בעצמו.
ה"שפתי חיים" מפתח הלאה רעיון זה; הוא כותב שכולנו מודעים לכך שאין לנו את היכולת להגיע לשום הישג בעולם הגשמי לולא הקב"ה שמסייענו. ואם כך, מדוע אנו משקיעים כל כך הרבה מאמצים בשטח זה? לאחר חטא אדם הראשון, הקב"ה גזר על האדם עבודת כפיים קשה שרק על ידה ישיג את פרנסתו - אולם אנו חייבים לזכור שהאמת היא שלא אנחנו מרויחים שום דבר כל פעולותינו מהוות אך ורק את ההשתדלות ההכרחית לנו בעקבות העונש של "בזעת אפיך תאכל לחם" כל עבודתנו והשתדלותנו להשיג את מחייתנו, ושאר הישגים גשמיים הינם תוצאה מאותה 'גזירת השתדלות', אנו נדרשים לעבוד ולהשקיע רבות, ועם זאת עלינו לזכור שבסופו של דבר לא המאמצים הם אלה שהביאו לפירות. מכל מקום, אנו הרבה פחות מודעים לכך שבאותה מידה נכונים הדברים גם בתחום הרוחני. אנו בעלי זכות בחירה, שהיא היכולת להחליט בעצמנו האם נבחר בטוב או חלילה ברע, ובכל מקרה, התוצאות הסופיות אינן נתונות בידיים שלנו! לדוגמא, ייתכן מצב בו אדם, ישקיע את מירב אונו והונו כדי לקנות אתרוג מהודר מאד, אולם כאשר הוא מגיע להשתמש בו ביום טוב, האתרוג יפול מידו והפיטם – ינתק מהאתרוג ויהפוך אותו לפסול לברכה. אנו יכולים להחליט לקיים את המצווה, אך רק הקב"ה הוא המאפשר לנו לקיימה למעשה.
בהתבסס על עקרון זה, ש"גזירת ההשתדלות" תקפה בתחום הגשמי כמו גם בתחום הרוחני, אדם עלול להגיע להשוואת שני עולמות אלה בדרך אחרת: האמונה והבטחון בה' חשובים יותר מהשקעה והשתדלות בעולם הגשמי, וככל שרמת הביטחון של האדם גבוהה יותר, כך הוא יוכל לקבל יותר, ללא יחס להשתדלות שהשקיע. אדם עלול לסגל גישה זהה גם ביחס לעולמו הרוחני – ולחשוב שהתפקיד העיקרי הוא להגיע לביטחון, ואילו ההשתדלות – רק מהווה גורם משני כתוצאה מגזירת ה'. אולם, מדגיש השפתי חיים – אין זה נכון להשוות באופן מוחלט בין העולם הרוחני והגשמי בהקשר זה. הוא מסביר שקיים הבדל מכריע ביניהם: בנוגע לגשמיות, ההשתדלות הינה חוב, שיש לשלמו, ולא טוב ולא ראוי שיוסיף על תשלום חובו יותר מהנדרש, על האדם להמעיט בהשתדלות עבור פרנסתו עד למינימום הנדרש. בניגוד לכך, בעבודת ה' עליו לעשות כל מאמץ אפשרי ולהשתדל בכל כוחו!.
רעיון זה מומחש יפה בסיפור הבא אודות ר' שרגא פייבל מנדלוביץ: "כבחור צעיר, היה הרצי שכטר מגיע באופן קבוע באיחור של כמה דקות לשיעורו של ר' שרגא פייבל בתנ"ך שהיה מתחיל ב: 9:00 בבוקר. יום אחד הוא קיבל הודעה שר' שרגא פייבל רוצה לדבר איתו. הרצי נכנס לחדר בחשש גלוי. "נו, הרצי, מתי תתחיל להגיע בזמן?" שאל הרב. הרצי נע באי נוחות מוגברת בכסאו, ולא הצליח לומר יותר מאשר "אם ירצה ה'". אולם ר' שרגא פייבל לא ויתר, וענה - "לא אם ירצה ה', אם ירצה הרצי!" יש מקרים בהם אסור לאדם להניח לעצמו מתוך ביטחון שה' ידאג לכך שהכל ילך באופן הטוב ביותר, אלא עליו לקחת על עצמו את מלא האחריות והיוזמה – הוא צריך לעשות.
אם קיימת טעות יסודית בהבנת תפקיד ומקומה של ההשתדלות האישית של כל אדם בעבודת ה' שלו, אזי בדיוק כך נראית תמונת המצב ביחס לשפל מצבו של העם היהודי בימינו. אדם עלול בקלות לנטות למחשבה שיהא המצב אשר יהא, בכל מקרה הקב"ה לא יניח לו להתדרדר ללא גבול ושליטה ושבסופו של דבר יסתדרו העניינים מאליהם. זוהי טעות חמורה ביותר; כל עוד בני אדם אינם קמים ופועלים כל שביכולתם על מנת לפתור את הבעיות בהן נתון העם היהודי כולו – תישארנה הבעיות בעינן. הקב"ה דורש מאיתנו לדאוג ולהביא לשיפור המצב ככל שביכלתנו. רעיון זה מובע במשנה בפרקי אבות: "במקום שאין אנשים השתדל להיות איש" מפרשים רבים מסבירים שהכוונה היא במקום בו חסרים אנשים שיפעלו למען הציבור, אדם חייב לקום ולמלא את החסר . ר' שמשון רפאל הירש כותב שבאופן רגיל אדם צריך לסגל לעצמו תכונות של צניעות וענווה ולברוח מהפרסום והכבוד, אולם כאשר קיים צורך לשרת את הציבור – במקום זה הצניעות והענווה לגמרי לא מתאימות. אלא אדם חייב לעשות כל שנצרך כדי לסייע ולעזור לציבור – אפילו במצב בו העניין כרוך בפרסום שהוא אינו חפץ בו . העובדה שהמשנה השתמשה במילה "השתדל" ראויה לשימת לב מיוחדת. אפשר היה לבחור בביטוי כמו – "במקום שאין אנשים – היה איש". התשובה לכך היא שהמילה "השתדל" מכוונת למאמצים גדולים; המשנה מלמדת אותנו שלא מספיק רק "לנסות" לעזור לציבור, אלא אדם צריך לנסות, ושוב לנסות ולהשתדל ולהתאמץ בכל כוחו כדי להשיג מטרות נעלות כאלה.
במשך חייו, משה רבנו שאף שאיפה אחת, והתאמץ והשתדל עבורה – למלא את רצון ה'. לכן, נתן לא הקב"ה את היכולת להגיע לתוצאות על אנושיות, כהרמת קרשי המשכן הכבדים מנשוא. אנו יכולים ללמוד מכך שכל מה שדורש מאיתנו ה' הוא שנשקיע את המאמץ הנדרש, התוצאות – תבאנה מידיו הרחבות והמלאות!
VAYAKHEL - SHABBOS
The Parsha begins with an exhortation to observe Shabbos: "For six days work will be done and the seventh day shall be holy for you, a day of complete rest for Hashem, whoever does work on it shall be put to death. " The commentaries ask that the wording of the Torah in this passuk needs explanation; it should have said, "for six days you will do work" in the active sense, rather than saying that work will be done in the passive form .
They explain that the Torah is teaching us about the attitude a person should have that will enable him to have the fortitude to refrain from doing melacha (prohibited activity) on Shabbos: Throughout the week a person is required to work in order to earn his livelihood, he cannot sit back and expect G-d to provide for him if he puts in no effort. He is required to put in hishtadlus because of the decree that Hashem placed upon mankind after the sin of Adam HaRishon. However, in truth , all his hishtadlus (effort) is not the reason for his success, rather Hashem is its sole Source. On Shabbos, Hashem commands us to refrain from creative activity to acknowledge this and that all the work we do in the week is only part of the gezeiras hishtadlus (decree to work). However, if one comes to believe that his physical efforts are in fact the cause of his livelihood then he will find it very difficult to refrain from working on Shabbos; he thinks that the more he works the more he will earn and therefore it is logical for him to work on Shabbos as well as the rest of the week. In response to this erroneous attitude, the Torah tells us that one should view the work that he does in a passive sense - that in truth he does not do the work, rather that it is done for him. Hashem, so-to-speak, does the work and provides for each person's livelihood. If one recognizes this then he will find it far easier to refrain from working on Shabbos because he realizes that in truth his work is not the cause of his livelihood .
It seems that this lesson is not limited to avoiding the 39 melachas that are forbidden by the Torah. There is a Rabbinical prohibition of speaking about melacha that one plans to do in the rest of the week . Doing so also shows a level of lack of appreciation of the lesson of Shabbos that Hashem provides one's livelihood. Moreover, whilst it is technically permissible to think about melacha on Shabbos, it is nonetheless praiseworthy to avoid such thoughts completely . Such a level reflects a true appreciation of how Shabbos is a reflection on the fact that Hashem runs the world, and that one's own thoughts of melacha are of no benefit.
This idea is brought out in the Gemara in Shabbos: The Gemara tells of a righteous man who saw that there was a hole in the fence of his field on Shabbos. He thought about fixing it after Shabbos, and then remembered that it was Shabbos and felt guilty about thinking about melacho on Shabbos. As a show of regret he then decided never to fix that fence and as a reward a miracle occurred and a tzlaf tree grew from which he was able to support himself and his family . There are two difficulties with this Gemara: Firstly, why did he refrain from ever fixing the fence - what was the benefit of doing so and how could it rectify his initial mistake? Secondly, what was the significance of the reward he received, how was that a measure for measure response to his decision never to build the fence?
It seems that we can answer these problems through the principle we are discussing. When this righteous man saw the fence, he thought about fixing it, momentarily forgetting the lesson of Shabbos, that Hashem is the Source of one's livelihood and that man's efforts are worthless without Hashem's help. In order to rectify this 'error' he decided to never fix the fence to demonstrate that he did indeed recognize that his own efforts were not the cause of his livelihood. As a reward for this attitude, Hashem showed him measure for measure that he was correct, and provided him with a new source of income, the tzlaf tree without any input from the man himself! This proved that Hashem can provide a person with his livelihood regardless of his hishtadlus.
Throughout the week it is very difficult to see through the illusion that man's hishtadlus is not the true cause of his livelihood, and that Hashem is the sole Provider. Shabbos provides man with the opportunity to see clearly that all his hishtadlus is ultimately unnecessary . On Shabbos whilst the rest of the world continues striving to earn their living through effort, observant Jews rest from such activity, recognizing that Hashem runs the world without needing man's input. As we have seen, this attitude does not only express itself through avoidance of melacha, it even extends to refraining from speaking about melacha. The highest level is to even avoid thinking about melacha that needs to be done. All these prohibitions are supposed to instill in us the realization that all our accomplishments throughout the week only come about because Hashem so desires. May we all merit to observe Shabbos free of action, speech and thought about melacha.
PEKUDEI - HISHTADLUS IN RUCHNIUS
After the Avodas Hamishkan was completed the workmen could not erect the Mishkan because of its massive weight. Since Moshe Rabbeinu had not had a share in the actual work of the Mishkan, Hashem wanted him to have the honor of erecting it. Hashem told him to make the attempt and the Mishkan would stand on its own, and it would appear to the onlookers as if he put it up himself .
This incident poses a difficulty - it seems clear that just as all the builders of the Mishkan were rewarded for their work, so too Moshe Rabbeinu was surely rewarded for the actual hakamas Hamishkan - why is this the case, he did not actually do anything, Hashem performed the erecting Himself?! In reality we are only able to perform any mitzvo because Hashem enables us to do so - Hashem is constantly sustaining the world and every human being in it - without this siata dishmaya we would not be able to do anything. The only difference in the case of the erecting of the Mishkan is that it was an open miracle whereas every mitzvo that we perform is a hidden miracle. The reward that we receive is not because of the result but because of the effort that we make. Moshe Rabbein made the effort to erect the Mishkan, therefore he was rewarded as if he performed it himself.
Sifsei Chaim develops this theme further; he writes that we all realize that we do not have the ability to achieve anything in gashmius without Hashem. If that is so, then why do we do so much activity? After chet Adam haRishon, Hashem decreed that man must exert physical effort in order to survive - however “we must realise that, in reality we do not achieve anything, all of our actions are only the exertion of the necessary effort which is a fulfillment of the passuk “you will eat bread by the sweat of your brow.” All of our work in earning our parnasa and other worldly activities are a result of this ‘gezeiras hishtadlus‘, we are required to expend such effort but we must recognize that ultimately it does not really achieve anything. However, we are less aware that the same is true even in the realm of ruchnius. We do have free will, which is the ability to decide whether we will choose good or bad, however, the final result is not in our control at all. For example, a person may expend great effort in buying a beautiful esrog, but when he comes to use it on Yom Tov he may drop the esrog and the pitom could break. We can make the decision to do the mitzva but only Hashem can actually enable us to completely fulfill it.
Based on the yesod that the gezeiras hishtadlus applies equally to gashmius and ruchnius, one may want to equate the two realms in another way: It is well known that bitachon is more important than hishtadlus in gashmius, and the more bitachon we have the more we will receive regardless of the hishtadlus that we put in. So too one may approach ruchnius with the same attitude - that the ikar avoda in ruchnius is bitachon and that hishtadlus is merely a secondary factor. However, Sifsei Chaim stresses that it is incorrect to totally equate ruchnius and gashmius in this regard - there is a crucial difference between the two: “In matters of gashmius, the required hishtadlus is a penalty that one must pay and it is not good to add to payment of the penalty [ie. one should minimize his hishtadlus as much as possible]. In contrast, in avodas Hashem he must do as much histhadlus as possible and strive with all his strength..”
This is a very important lesson; we generally recognize that bitachon is an essential aspect of avodas Hashem and that our own hishtadlus should be minimized as much as possible, however one may also have the same attitude in spiritual matters; he may limit his hishtadlus in ruchnius with the mistaken assumption that he can trust in Hashem to do the work for him - this is a serious mistake for, as Sifsei Chaim explains, in ruchnius there is no limit to how much effort one should expend. This idea is illustrated by the following story involving Rav Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz zt”l. “As a teenager, Hertzl Shechter was invariably a few minutes late for Reb Shraga Feivel’s 9.00am Tanach shiur, and one day he received a notice that ‘the Boss’ wanted to speak to him. Shechter entered the room trembling. “Nu, Hertzl, when are you going to start coming on time?” Reb Shraga Feivel asked. Shifting uncomfortably in his seat, Shechter could manage nothing more than, “Im yirtzeh Hashem.” But Reb Shraga Feivel was not to be put off so easily. “Nein,” he began shaking his head, “not im yirtzeh Hashem, Im yirtzeh Hertzl - no, not if Hashem wants; rather if Hertzl wants.” There are times when a person should not comfort himself with the fact that Hashem will ensure that everything runs smoothly, rather he must take the intiative himself.
If there is a misconception about the role of hishtadlus in one’s own personal avodas Hashem, then this is certainly the case with regard to the state of Klal Yisroel. One may easily be tempted to think that, no matter how bad the situation is, Hashem will not let it deteriorate indefinitely and that we can trust that eventually things will improve ‘mimayla’. Chazal teach us that this is a grave error; if people do not take action to resolve the problems of Klal Yisrael then they will only persist - Hashem requires us to bring about an improvement through our own efforts. This idea is expressed in the Mishna in Pirkei Avos: “In a place where there are no men hishtadel [strive] to be a man.” Many commentaries explain this to mean that when there is a lack of people serving the needs of the Klal, one must stand up and fill the gap. Rav Hirsch zt”l writes that in normal circumstances one should be humble and avoid publicity, however when people are needed to serve the klal then humility and tsnius are totally inappropriate, rather one should do whatever is necessary to improve the situation even if it involves receiving unwanted publicity. It is noteworthy that the Mishna chose to use the word, ‘histhadel’ when it could have simply said ‘in a place where there are no men be a man.” The reason for this is that the word, ‘hishtadel’ implies great effort; the Mishna is teaching us that it is not enough to merely ‘try’ to help the community, rather, one must exert great effort into the task at hand.
The Alter of Novardok stressed the need for such exertion in the battle to uphold the Torah. “When a person becomes aware of as grievous a failing within society as its present educational structure, which has taken such a tremendous toll on our youth - how much must he summon up all of his powers to guard the breach, remove the impediment and raise up the standard of truth…. there is no alternative but to rouse ourselves from our slumber, consider the dangers which confront us and go out with energy and drive, and use all our talents and sensitivities to do all that we are able.” One may argue that there is a great limit to what a single person can achieve even if he expends much effort: The Alter seems to have thought differently: He once said that, “if a person works as hard for the benefit of the public as he works for the benefit of a single member of his family, he could found a hundred yeshivas!”
Throughout his life, Moshe Rabbeinu was willing to extend great effort to fulfill the Ratson Hashem - as a result Hashem gave him the ability to achieve superhuman results such as lifting the beams of the Mishkan. We can learn from this that all Hashem requires is that we extend the effort, the results are in Hashem’s hands.
VAYAKHEL – ONE DEED REFLECTS ON ANOTHER
The Torah describes how the people eagerly came to donate their prized possessions towards the building of the Mishkan (Tabernacle). “The men came with the women; everyone whose heart motivated him brought bracelets, nose-rings, body ornaments – all sorts of gold ornaments – every man who raised up an offering of gold to HaShem.” The commentaries discuss the meaning of the phrase, “the men came with the women”.
Rabbeinu Bechaye explains that the women in fact came first to donate their jewelry, and the men only came after them. This, he explains, demonstrates their righteousness in and of itself but it also reflects positively on an earlier incident involving jewelry – that of the Golden Calf. When the men demanded that Aaron make for them a statue, he told them to remove the women’s jewelry. However, the women refused to give over their jewelry so the men took their own gold and gave that towards the building of the Calf. From the incident of the Golden Calf alone, it is unclear why the women refused to give their jewelry. It was possible that their main motivation was their natural attachment to their jewelry, as opposed to the pure motivation of refusal to be involved with the sin of the Golden Calf. However, in Parshas Vayakhel we see that the women were very willing to donate their jewelry towards the elevated purpose of the building of the Mishkan. This retroactively teaches us about the reason that they did not give their jewelry at the Golden Calf. It was not because of their attachment to gold and silver, because that did not prevent the women from parting with them for the sake of the Mishkan. Rather, their refusal to give towards the Golden Calf emanated from leshem Shamayim (pure) motives - they wanted no part in that terrible sin.
Rav Avraham Pam zt”l derives a very important concept from this explanation. It is known in Hebrew as ‘Maasim shel adam mochichim zeh es zeh’. This means that the actions of a person in one area can reveal something about his actions in another area. In this case, the women’s willingness to part with their jewelry for the Mishka, revealed their pure intentions when refusing to do so for the Golden Calf.
We see another example of this concept with regards to one of the names given to the Third meal that is eaten on Shabbos: Shalosh Seudas – this literally means, ‘three meals’. This is a very strange name to give the third meal, it would be more appropriate to only use its other name – seudah shelishis. Why is this meal also known as ‘three meals’? The answer is that the way a person conducts himself at the third meal reflects retroactively on his intentions during the first two Shabbos meals. There are two possible reasons as to why a person would eat well at the first two Shabbos meals: It could be because of his pure desire to honor the Shabbos by eating delicious food, or it could emanate from his hunger and desire to eat well, because both those meals come at a time when a person is normally hungry and ready to eat well. However, the third meal comes quite soon after Shabbos lunch, therefore a person’s natural hunger will not be high. If he refrains from eating at the third meal despite the fact that it is a Mitzvo to eat then, he retroactively shows that his main kavannah for the first two meals was to fill his stomach more than honor the Shabbos! If, however, he does partake in a delicious meal he demonstrates that his intentions are for the honor of Shabbos, for if it were not Shabbos he would otherwise eat far less or nothing at all. Accordingly, by eating the third meal he retroactively demonstrates his intent for the first two, and at this point it is clear that he ate ALL THREE MEALS with pure intentions. Therefore, the third meal merits the name, ‘three meals’ because, for one who eats the third meal, it is considered as if he ate all three meals with pure intent.
This concept of ‘Maasim shel adam mochichim zeh es zeh’ is of great importance because it is a very effective mechanism in judging the consistency of people’s actions. This idea is brought out by the Beis HaLevi on Parshas Vayigash. When Yosef revealed himself to his brothers he asked them the question; “is my father still alive? ” When the brothers heard this, they were completely speechless and disconcerted. The Medrash compares Yosef’s revelation to his brothers to that of the Day of Judgment. It says that if the brothers could not answer Yosef who was younger than them, then all the more so when HaShem (so to speak) comes and rebukes us, we will be left speechless. The commentaries ask; what exactly is the comparison between Yosef’s revelation to the brothers and the Day of Judgment.
The Beis HaLevi answers by first explaining Yosef’s question about whether his father was alive – it was very clear from the events up to this time that Yaakov Avinu was still alive! He answers that Yosef was in truth giving them a veiled rebuke. Yehuda had just spent a great deal of time arguing that Yosef should not take Binyomin as a slave because it would destroy Yaakov. By bringing up the well-being of Yaakov, Yosef was alluding to them that their purported concern for their father did not seem to be consistent with their actions in selling Yosef so many years earlier. At that time, they had shown no concern for the pain that their father would feel al the loss of his beloved son. In this way, the brothers had contradicted their own arguments through their very actions! The Beis HaLevi then explains the similarity of Yosef’s ‘rebuke’ to that of the Day of Judgment. On that awesome day each person will be asked about his various actions, including his sins and failure to keep Mitzvos properly. He may have excuses, however, these excuses will then be scrutinized by his other actions in that same area. For example, a person might justify his failure to give sufficient money to charity on the basis that he was lacking in his own livelihood. However, his spending in other areas will then be examined – if it becomes clear that in other areas he was all too willing and able to spend large amounts of money, then he himself has ruined his own justification for failing to give charity! In this vein, his actions in spending money for his own enjoyment reflects badly on his spending of money for the Mitzvo of giving charity.
In this vein, the Choftez Chaim once berated a wealthy man for giving insufficient funds to charity. The man answered that he did indeed give away a significant amount. The Chofetz Chaim then worked out the amount of money he gave to charity and compared it to his expenses on his own luxuries. It came out that the man spent more money on his drapery alone than on all the charity that he gave!
We have discussed the concept of ‘Maasim shel adam mochichim zeh es zeh’ and seen its great significance in the process of judgment. The obvious lesson to be derived from this concept, is that it is essential that a person analyze the consistency of his actions. For example, a person who claims that he does not have enough time to learn will have to justify his failure to learn on the Day of Judgment. If it becomes clear that he did have enough time for many other types of activities then his claim that he did not have enough time to learn will be put in serious jeopardy. His actions in other areas show that in truth it wasn’t because he did not have enough time to learn, rather that it was a very low priority in his list of importance. It would be much less disconcerting if we can make our own self-analysis of such inconsistencies and fix them before the Day of Judgment. May we all merit to achieve consistency in all our actions.
Friday, March 1, 2013
PEKUDEI – THE VALUE OF THE TABERNACLE
“These are the reckonings of the Tabernacle, the Tabernacle of Testimony, which was reckoned at Moshe’s bidding. The labor of the Levites was under the authority of Issamar, son of Aaron the Kohen. Betzalel, son of Uri, son of Hur, of the tribe of Yehudah, did everything that HaShem commanded Moshe.”
The Parsha begins with a brief description of the Mishkan (Tabernacle) and the people who were involved in its construction and service. The Seforno writes that the Torah is teaching us a significant point with this introduction. The Mishkan and its accessories were never destroyed, captured or desecrated. In contrast, both the Temples were subject to desecration and destruction. The Seforno explains that the first two verses in the Parsha are giving four reasons behind the elevated nature of the Mishkan. The first is in the words; “‘the Tabernacle of Testimony”. This, the Seforno explains refers to the two Tablets that Moshe received on Mount Sinai. These are indicative of the incredible spirituality that dwelt in the Tabernacle. The verse continues; “which was reckoned at Moshe’s bidding.” Since Moshe arranged the building of the Mishkan, it benefitted from his personal majesty. The third aspect contributing to the holiness of the Mishkan was that, “the labor of the Levites was under the authority of Issamar”. Issamar was also a man of great stature. And finally, the second verse informs us that Betzalel, also a great man, with great lineage, built the Mishkan.
The Seforno then contrasts this with the people involved in the building of the Temples. The first Temple was arranged by the righteous Shlomo HaMelech, however, the workers were non-Jews from Tsur. Since the Temple was not built by righteous people, it was subject to corrosion and therefore needed to be maintained, unlike the Tabernacle. Moreover, because of its lower level of holiness it did ultimately fall into the hands of our enemies and was destroyed. The second Temple was of an even lower level of holiness; the Tablets were not there, and it was arranged by Koresh (Cyrus), the Persian King. Accordingly, it too fell foul of our enemies and was destroyed.
Three verses later, the Torah tells us the total value of all the jewelry that was given for the building of the Tabernacle. The Seforno on this verse, continuing in his theme from the earlier verses, notes that the total material value of the Tabernacle was far less than that of both Temples, both of which were incredibly beautiful and expensive buildings. And yet, unlike the Temples, the humble Tabernacle continually had the Divine Presence within it. The Seforno concludes that this teaches us that the holiness of a building is not defined by its material value and beauty, rather by the spiritual level of the people who were involved it its construction. In a similar vein, the explanation of the Seforno teaches us that the Torah outlook attributes true value towards physical objects or buildings in a very different way to that of the secular outlook. In the secular world, the external beauty or material value of the item define its ‘value’. In contrast, the Torah pays little heed to the external qualities rather the internal spirituality that was invested into the item determines its true value. Thus, the Tabernacle may have been far less physically impressive than the two Temples but its true value was far greater because of the intentions of the people who made it.
This concept is demonstrated by an interesting incident with regard to the Tabernacle that is described in Parshas Terumah and Vayakhel. HaShem instructs Moshe Rabbeinu to tell the people to bring the raw materials necessary in order to build the Mishkan. "This is the portion that you shall take from them: gold, silver, and copper; and turquoise, purple and scarlet wool; linen and goat hair; red-dyed ram skins; tachash skins, acacia wood; oil for illumination, spices for the anointment oil and the aromatic incense; shoham stones and stones for the settings, for the Ephod and Breastplate ." The Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh points out that the order of the materials mentioned is difficult to understand; the shoham stones and the 'stones of the settings' are the most valuable of all the items in the list, therefore logically they should have been mentioned first. He offers an answer based on the Gemara that informs us how the people attained the shoham stones. The Gemara says that a great miracle occurred and shoham stones came down along with the manna. The Nesi’im (Princes) then donated these precious stones to the Mishkan.. One may think that the supernatural manner in which the stones came down would only add to their inherent material value. However, the Ohr HaChaim writes the exact opposite; since the stones came without any effort or financial loss, they are placed at the end of the list of items donated to the Mishkan. When the people gave all the other items, they were parting with their property and willingly undergoing financial loss for the sake of doing HaShem’s will. This places those items, including such mundane material as goat hair, on a higher level than the precious shoham stones who came through a miracle. This starkly demonstrates the Torah’s value system with regard to the physical world. External factors are completely subjugated to the internal – the intentions that went into the item determine its true value.
This concept has applications in Jewish law. The authorities discuss the status of an esrog that has been bruised by over-use. The Chasam Sofer zt”l rules that if the bruises came about because many people fulfilled the Mitzvo of shaking the four species with this esrog, then it is kosher. He writes further that the fact that the bruises came about through Mitzvos actually enhances its status, and constitutes a kind of hiddur (beautification) in and of itself. This Chasam Sofer teaches us a very telling lesson. When a person would see a beautiful, clean esrog that had never been used, and compares it to a bruised esrog that had been shaken by hundreds of people, he would consider the clean esrog to be of greater value. However, the Torah focuses far more on the internal value behind the esrog, than on its external beauty. In a similar vein, a man’s hat once became very dirty on Shabbos. He asked the Chazon Ish zt”l if he could clean it on Shabbos. The Chazon Ish answered that it was forbidden, but he man argued that it is not Kavod Shabbos (the honor of Shabbos) to go around with a dirty hat. The Chazon Ish answered that since the hat is left dirty in honor of the sanctity of Shabbos, in this case, keeping it dirty constitutes honoring the Shabbos itself. Again, one may think that a dirty hat cheapens Shabbos due to its unkempt appearance, however, in truth the intentions that lay behind the dirt can turn this into a way of greatly honoring Shabbos!
We have seen how the Torah’s criterion for defining the true ‘value’ of the physical world is very different from that of the secular world. The effort, kavannah (intentions) and spiritual input into that item are the true determinants of its objective value, as opposed to its superficial appearance or monetary value. There is a very natural tendency for a person brought up in the Western world or with Western influences to focus on the externalities of the physical world, including the size of a house, the appearance of a car, etc. The sources above teach us that it is incumbent on each person to adjust his value system in line with the Torah outlook. .
PARSHAS PARAH - TAAMEI HAMITZVOS
Every year, a few weeks before Pesach, we read the section about the mitzvo of parah adumah. (the red heifer). Accordingly, this mitzvo teaches us very important life lessons.
The Ohr HaChaim Hakadosh asks why this mitzvo is called the ‘chok (statute) of the Torah’, it would have been more appropriate to say ‘this is the chok of tahara (purity)’. He answers that the Torah is alluding to us that if we fulfil this mitzvo even though it has no reason to it, then the Passuk considers it as if we have fulfilled the whole Torah, because fulfilling a mitzva without reason shows that we are unconditionally willing to follow Hashem’s Ratson.
Rav Chaim Shmuelevitz zt”l explains that when a person fulfils a mitzvo that has an obvious reason to it, it is still not clear that he is prepared to fulfil the Torah purely because Hashem commanded it. It could be that he is doing it because it makes sense to him. However, once he performs a mitzvo that is without logic that proves that he keeps all the mitzvos, not because they make sense to him, but because Hashem commanded them.
This is a fundamental principle of the Torah - we accept that we must follow Hashem’s will without making any cheshbonos (calculations) according to our own logic. Rav Moshe Feinstein zt”l writes that this was Korach’s mistake in his theological attacks against Moshe Rabbeinu. He attempted to expose the fallacy of the mitzvos of tsitsit and mezuza by showing their illogical nature. He argued that the reason for wearing a thread of techeiles on each corner is because it resembles the sea, which resembles the sky, which resembles the Throne of Glory. Based on this reasoning Korach argued that one who wears a garment of techeiles should not need a thread of it on its corner because there is ample reminder of the sea, sky and the throne of glory in the actual garment. In reality, however, the mitzvo applies in all cases, even where the given reason has no apparent application because ultimately all mitzvos must be observed and should be viewed as a gezeira (decree) that cannot be questioned.
In light of this principle, a difficulty arises: Many of the greatest Torah scholars such as the Rambam, Sefer HaChinuch and, more recently, Rav Samson Raphael Hirsch zt”l went to great lengths to explain the taamey hamitzvos - the reasons behind the mitzvos. Yet it is clear from Parah Adumah that the ultimate reason behind each mitzvo is beyond human
understanding. Shlomo Hamelech had thought that he understood the deepest reason for every mitzvo until he came to Parah Aduma which he could not fathom. He then realized that he did not truly understand the definitive reason for any of the mitzvos. In light of this, how can anyone claim to understand a reason for any given mitzvo if Shlomo Hamelech, the wisest man, could not?!
My Rebbe answers by explaining that the commentaries are not claiming to understand the ultimate reason behind the mitzvo. We can have no concept of the genuine reason for any mitzvo, that is something that belongs in the highest olamos. However, this does not mean that the ‘taamey hamitzvos’ have no truth to them. Hashem, in his infinite wisdom ‘arranged’ it so that each mitzvo can make sense on many different levels of existence. For example they can help a person develop desirable character traits and can enhance relationships.
We see this in many mitzvos: The laws of purity are among the most difficult to fathom. However, the most relevant of these laws today, family purity (taharas mishpacha), has obvious benefits. The Gemara explains that it is very beneficial for husband and wife to separate for a certain time every month so that they can avoid the problem of lack of excitement in the relationship . Based on this Gemara, the Sefer Hachinuch writes that this advantage is one of the taamey hamitzvos of taharas mishpacha . This does not mean that the reason we keep taharas mishpacha is because it helps one’s relationship. However, it is no co-incidence that it does so, Hashem clearly ‘intended’ it to be that way.
Another example of this is the mitzvo of how to properly slaughter an animal (shechita). The Ramban writes that it does not effect Hashem whether we kill an animal by shechita or by strangling. However, Hashem instructed us to kill the animal in the least cruel way in order to teach us the trait (midda) of being merciful even at the time of killing . This does not mean that we slaughter animals the way we do because it will help us be more merciful, we do it that way purely because Hashem commanded us to. Nevertheless this does not take away from the fact that Hashem also intended for us to develop favorable middos through observing the mitzvos.
Thus, notwithstanding the fact that we cannot fathom the ultimate reason for the mitzvos, we can nonetheless understand taamim to the mitzvos that are true on a certain level. With this understanding we can now appreciate why the commentaries held it was so important to teach us taamey hamitzvos. It is true that we keep the mitzvos solely because Hashem instructed us to, however, it is not sufficient that we merely do the mitzvo robotically, without any thought as to what we are doing. Mitzvos are intended to change us into better people, and the way that they do this is through the taamey hamitzvos. The Sefer Hachinuch tells us the shoresh (root) to every mitzvo - why? So that we can have an idea of what we are supposed to gain from performing this mitzvo and we can work towards achieving that benefit.
The prohibition of lashon hara (negative speech) demonstrates this idea. Rabbeinu Yonah explains the taam of this prohibition with a story. A wise man was walking with his students when they came across the corpse of a dead dog. One of the students commented on how disgusting this corpse was. The wise man replied that it had very nice, white teeth . He was teaching his student the midda of focusing on the good. This, Rabbeinu Yonah writes, is the taam of shemiras halashon. There is no actual prohibition of lashon hara for focusing on the unpleasant aspects of a dead dog, however one who sees things in a negative fashion misses the point about lashon hara. It is not enough merely to not speak badly about others, the root of the mitzvo is to focus on the good in people. In refraining from speaking badly about others, one should strive to transform himself into a person with a positive outlook on life.
We have seen how parah aduma teaches us that we are obligated to fulfil mitzvos without questioning their logic, and yet at the same time, we are also obligated to understand the taamim of the mitzvos so that we can grow from them in the intended way.
A recommended way to achieve this is to spend some time analyzing the taamey hamitzvos. There are many sources, one can look to the earlier sources such as Rambam in Moreh Nevuchim and Sefer Hachinuch or turn to later commentaries such as Rav Hirsch or Rav Aryeh Kaplan zt”l. By doing this we can remind ourselves that each mitzvo has taamim that we are supposed to be aware of and use to grow from.
This is not an easy task because there is a strong yetser hara that allows us to do mitzvos as long as we miss their intended purpose The story is told of a great Rabbi who visited a home for the Friday night meal. As he and his host entered the house, they saw that the challah had not been covered as is the custom. The host, upset at this failing in front of his honored guest, proceeded to berate his hapless wife in front of his guest. After this outburst, the Rabbi gently took him aside and asked him if he knew why we cover the challah? The reason is so as not to embarrass it when we bless on the wine before it. By embarrassing his wife the host demonstrated that he had clearly not internalized the message of this custom. All the mitzvos have internal messages - it is up to us to learn them and use them in their intended way.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)