Wednesday, February 6, 2013
MISHPATIM - COMPLETE KINDNESS
In Parshas Mishpatim the Torah instructs us with regard to lending money to our fellow in need. The Torah states: "When you lend money to My people, to the poor person who is with you, do not act toward him as a creditor; do not lay interest upon him. If you take your fellow's garment as security until sunset, you shall return it to him. For it alone is his clothing, it is his garment for his skin - in what should he lie down? - so it will be if he cries out to Me, I shall listen, for I am compassionate. "
On superficial analysis these Mitzvos seem to be fairly straightforward and easy to understand, however Rav Chaim Shmuelevitz zt"l derives a very important insight about the Torah's attitude to chesed (kindness) from these passukim : This passage is dealing with a person who fulfills the great kindness of helping his friend by lending him money, and yet the Torah gives him a number of Mitzvos to ensure that he perform this chesed in the most optimum way and not diminish its effect. It is instructive to analyze these passukim more carefully to note their common theme:
"Do not act toward him as a creditor." Rashi, based on the Mechilta, explains that this means that if the lender knows that the borrower is, at present, unable to pay back the loan, then the lender should not make him feel pressured about it, rather he should behave as if the loan never took place, so as not to embarrass the borrower. "Do not lay interest upon him." This refers to the prohibition of lending money with interest (ribbis). Rav Shmuelevitz brings a number of Maamrei Chazal that emphasize the seriousness of lending with interest; for example he brings a Medrash that for every sin there are Malachim (angels) in shamayim who try to find a merit for the sinner, the one exception to this case being that of ribbis. Rav Shmuelievitz points out that the severity for lending with interest is difficult to understand. It is clear that even one who lends with a small amount of interest, is doing a great chesed to the borrower who is in urgent need of money immediately and is prepared to pay the extra interest at a later date. Nonetheless the Torah treats this person very strictly.
"If you take your fellow's garment as security until sunset, you shall return it to him." When the borrower is unable to pay back the loan the lender is permitted to take his personal items as collateral to ensure payment of the loan. However, he must return the items when they are needed by the borrower. For example, clothing is needed in the daytime, therefore the lender may only keep it in the night and must return it in the day so that the borrower can use it. This law seems to nullify the whole function of collateral, for if the borrower can still use it when he needs it, he will be far less motivated to pay back the loan. Nonetheless, the Torah demands that the lender respect the borrower's basic needs.
Rav Shmuelevitz explains that the common denominator of these laws is that they stress the importance of doing chesed in as complete a manner as possible, without lessening the effect of the chesed. Consequently, even though it is a great Mitzvo to lend someone money, the lender must be extremely careful not to diminish the effect of his kindness through pressuring the borrower in any fashion. Rav Shmuelevitz says further that the greater a person's appreciation of the importance of chesed, the more strictly he is treated when he fails to act according to his recognition. Thus, one who lends and yet charges interest, is treated particularly harshly because he appreciates the value of helping the borrower, and nonetheless he chooses to charge him with interest.
Rav Moshe Sternbuch Shlita derives a similar lesson from a very puzzling Gemara. The Gemara says that a person who begins a Mitzvo but does not complete it, is punished very severely - this seems difficult to understand - there is no such punishment for one who does not perform a Mitzvo at all, and yet one who at least begins a Mitzvo is punished so badly! Rav Sternbuch answers that this Gemara teaches us that one who starts a Mitzvo demonstrates that he has an appreciation of the value of the Mitzvo. Consequently, if he fails to complete it, he is treated more harshly because of his heightened appreciation of the need for the Mitzvo. In contrast, one who does not even begin the Mitzvo is not punished because he is on a lower level and therefore is judged in a more lenient manner.
We learn from the Mitzvos relating to lending money that when a person is doing a chesed for his fellow it is essential that he strive to maximize the positive effect of his chesed and not let it be tainted in any way. This applies in many instances in our daily lives; very often a person is approached to do some kind of favor; he may agree to do it, but with a reluctance that makes the person in need feel uncomfortable about inconveniencing him. Rather, the giver should strive to be as positive as possible about helping his friend. This greatly enhances the actual positive benefit at results, because, as well as being helped, the person in need is not made to feel guilty about his request. Similarly when one gives tzedoko he can do it with a smile or with a sour face. Chazal tell us that one who gives with simcha, receives no less than 17 brachos for his Mitzvo, whereas one who gives unenthusiastically only receives 6 brachos . One does a chesed with a lack of enthusiasm greatly diminishes the effect of his kindness.
One final example is when one asks someone else to do a chesed in a particular way and he agrees, but the giver may not take care to do it according to the requirements of the one in need. For example, a wife may ask her husband to clean the house of the mess that has accumulated. He may well have a different conception of a 'tidy' house from that of his wife and only tidy up according to his assessment of what is required. In truth, however, he knows that his wife would like him to clear up according to her level of tidiness. In order to do this chesed properly he should strive to do it in the manner that she requires. We have seen that the Mitzvos with regard to lending teach us the importance of doing chesed in as complete a manner as possible. May we all merit to help others in the most effective way possible.
MISHPATIM – INSIGHTS IN RASHI – MOSHE AND YEHOSHUA
Shemos, 24:13: “And Moshe stood up with Yehoshua, his servant, and Moshe ascended to the Mountain of G-d.”
Rashi, 24:13, sv. And Moshe stood up with Yehoshua: “I don’t know what the function of Yehoshua is here: I say that he was the student accompanying his teacher until the place of the boundaries on the mountain, because he wasn’t allowed to go further. And from there, Moshe ascended alone to the Mountain of G-d and Yehoshua set up his tent and stayed there for the whole forty days…”
In the end of Parshas Mishpatim, Rashi reveals Yehoshua’s great loyalty to his rebbe, Moshe Rabbeinu. He faithfully followed Moshe as far as he could, and when he could go no further, he isolated himself away from the nation in order to be as close to Moshe as possible. This dedication to his Rebbe and desire to spend every available moment in his company was the key to Yehoshua’s greatness and eventual accession to the leadership of the Jewish nation.
Chazal enumerate many instances of Yehoshua showing his submission to his Rebbe. The Torah describes him as Moshe’s attendant , and Chazal explain that he would take towels to the bathhouse for him and would rise early every morning and select the largest of the manna and give it to Moshe . In Torah learning he dedicated himself to understanding and emulating his Rebbe to the extent that the Talmud Yerushalmi says that even in matters that he had not heard from Moshe, his own reasoning corresponded with what had been told to Moshe at Sinai . Yehoshua was completely content with his role as second to Moshe; he did not feel as though it belittled his own standing, rather he felt it elevated him to incredible heights.
Indeed the Medrash tells us that it was the merit of Yehoshua’s submission to Moshe that caused him to become the leader of Klal Yisrael: “HaShem told Moshe, Yehoshua constantly served you and accorded you much honor. He came early to your house of assembly to arrange the benches and spread the mats. Since he served you with all his might, he is worthy of serving Israel. ” Yehoshua happily accepted his role as ‘number two’ and consequently attained the ultimate position of leader of Klal Yisrael.
One of the lessons to be derived from Yehoshua is the importance of dibbuk chachamim, clinging to Torah scholars. Yehoshua’s example teaches us that it is not sufficient to merely ask the Rav a lot of questions - rather one must cleave to him at every posible moment, thereby using every moment as an opportunity to learn first-hand how a Talmid Chacham conducts himself. May we all merit to learn this lesson.
Wednesday, January 30, 2013
YISRO - THE ART OF LISTENING
YISRO - THE ART OF LISTENING
One of the striking features of Parshas Yisro is the juxtaposition of the portion about Yisro’s advice to Moshe Rabbeinu with Matan Torah. Reb Tzadok HaKohen provides an interesting insight to this in the name of his Rebbe . He begins by discussing the section in which Yisro advises Moshe to change the judicial system and Moshe accepts his advice. This seems quite unremarkable but on reflection a tremendous mida of Moshe Rabbeinu is displayed in his reaction to Yisro’s advice. Yisro may have been a wise man but he was surely far below the level of his great son-in-law and, moreover had no exposure to the wisdom of Torah. Moshe could have easily heard out his advice and then politely reject it without really considering its application. Instead he listened attentively and gave great thought to the advice and ultimately decided to follow it. Reb Tzadok’s Rebbe says that we learn from Moshe that a person should listen to the words of a hedyot and that this is an aspect of learning from every man. He then explains the juxtaposition with Matan Torah by saying that this lesson is the introduction to Matan Torah because an essential part of learning Torah is the ability to learn it from everyone.
One may ask that the ability to listen to others may be of some benefit in learning Torah but surely it is not of such great significance that it should be the main introductory lesson leading up to Matan Torah. Rav Elyah Lopian zt”l answers this question: He writes, “there are people who are masmidim and who toil in Torah, but they do not have the ability to listen to others and to connect with their friends in Torah learning, rather, they are totally engrossed in themselves and their own ‘daled amos’. Such people are not only punished severely, but moreover they will not succeed in their learning whatsoever.” He goes on to explains why the lack of the ability to listen hinders one’s learning so badly. “A person is naturally favorably biased towards himself and is blinded to anything that goes against his opinion. He cannot clarify anything accurately if he won’t listen to what anyone else says. ”
It seems that man’s innate inability to hear views that contradict his own can even prevent a talmid from listening properly even to those more learned than himself. There is a particular tendency to want to argue with whatever they say - consequently the talmid can never really understand and absorb what his superior is telling him. In contrast, the ability to wholeheartedly listen and comprehend what others are saying is one of the keys to Gadlus. The Alter of Novardok zt”l expressed this point when extolling the greatness of Rav Chaim Ozer Grodzensky zt”l. “His wisdom and genius is so great and of so much depth and breadth, because when he was young he was always to be found in the presence of the Gedoley Hador. He never said to them, ‘accept my opinion’, rather he made himself into a ‘vessel’ which would listen and absorb all the opinions and explanations of all the Gedolim there. He absorbed into his very being all the wisdom that he heard and his daas became purified and elevated by the greatness of many generations that became embedded in his mind. ” When we discuss the greatness of Rav Chaim Ozer we generally focus on his incredible natural genius and ability to think of many things at the same time. We see from the words of the Alter that the key to his greatness was his willingness to take in everything that he heard.
Whilst there is a challenge to give our full attention to our Rabbeim it is far more difficult to listen effectively to our peers. Often when we hear that a certain person is about to say over an idea or dvar Torah we mentally ‘switch off’ and think about what we want to say next. Apart from showing a lack of derech eretz, such an attitude severely hinders a person’s ability to grow in wisdom.
The ability to accept someone else’s opinion, especially when it contradicts one’s own, is an all too rare quality. At one seudas preida, one of the speakers was extolling the virtues of his friend - he told over that they were once having a heated debate about a certain issue and seemed to end the conversation ‘agreeing to disagree’. Later on, he came to his friend and said that he heard where he was coming from and had now changed his opinion on this matter because of their conversation. There are two striking things about this story - one is the person’s gadlus in hearing out a contradictory view and even accepting it when it made sense. The second is that this mida is obviously so rare that it was the one chosen to describe the maalos of this person. In truth, this should not be the case - it should be a matter of course that when we are involved in a discussion with someone that we actually ‘listen’ to what they are saying and try to learn from them even if it goes against our original way of thinking.
Even more difficult than hearing out our peers is effectively listening to those on a lower level than ourselves. One senior bachur in a yeshiva was troubled by the Mishna in Avos that tells us that the very definition of a wise man is one who can learn from every man, not just Gedolim - he asked a distinguished posek, that there is surely nothing to learn from those on a far lower level of learning. To this, the posek answered that he had taught Mishna Berurah to baaley teshuva who had been learning Torah for about one year. He said that they approached the halachos from angles that he had never experienced before which made him seriously rethink many yesodos that he had come to accept.
We learn from Parshas Yisro that listening to others is one of the very foundations of wisdom. Many commentaries say that this is what the second of the 48 devarim is referring to when it says that ‘shemias haozen’ is a way of acquiring Torah. May we all gain the ability to genuinely listen to what our teacher, friend, or talmid is saying and this should help us learn and understand the Torah.
YISRO: RAV NOACH WEINBERG ZT"L
YISRO: RAV NOACH WEINBERG ZT"L
"I am the Lord, Your G-d, who took you out of the land of Mitzrayim from being slaves. "
The First of the Ten Commandments is the Mitzva of Emuna, to believe in the one G-d as the first cause of all existence, who constantly creates and sustains all of creation . There is another fundamental concept that is connected to Emuna, that of Bitachon, trust in G-d. Is trusting in G-d a part of the Mitzva of Emuna or is it a separate concept that is not included in any specific Mitzva? The Chazon Ish zt"l explains that Bitachon is not separate at all, rather it is the natural outgrowth of genuine Emuna; The obligation to have Emuna requires that one believe in the fundamental tenets about G-d such as First Cause and Hashgacha (Divine Providence), whereas Bitachon is applying that belief in practice. If a person cannot do this then it reveals that his Emuna is severely lacking. The Chazon Ish gives an example of Reuven who is constantly expressing his Emuna and how everything that he has is from Hashem; he proclaims his recognition that his livelihood emanates purely from Hashem and that there is no need for anxiety. However, when someone else opens a business that rivals that of Reuven, suddenly, all his Emuna fades away and he worries constantly over the future. Reuven's Emuna seemed to be strong when everything was going smoothly, but when he was put to the test he failed to show sufficient Bitachon. This in turn demonstrates that his Emuna was never genuine .
We learn from the Chazon Ish that an essential aspect of Emuna is bitachon, which means applying one's Emuna to real life situations. The Nesivos Shalom zt"l develops our understanding of Bitachon by explaining that there are two levels of Bitachon. There is an inactive kind of Bitachon and there is a proactive Bitachon. Inactive bitachon applies when one finds himself in a difficult situation in which there is nothing he can do - in such circumstances his Avoda is to trust that everything that happens will ultimately be for the good. Proactive bitachon becomes necessary when a person is required to do something that demonstrates his trust in Hashem. He cites the example of Krias Yam Suf (the splitting of the Sea of Reeds); Moshe Rabbeinu and the Jewish people were crying out to Hashem to save them from Pharaoh's advancing army. In response, Hashem told them to stop praying and to go into the sea. The Nesivos Shalom explains that in order for the Jewish people to merit Hashem transcending nature through Krias Yam Suf they had to demonstrate a trust in Hashem that transcended the normal laws of nature. They had to believe that if the Ratson Hashem (will of Hashem) was for them to cross the sea then they should trust that He had the ability to enable them to do so, even if they had no idea how it was possible. Accordingly, their stepping into the raging sea before it split was a display of proactive bitachon that earned them the right to the great miracle of Krias Yam Suf .
By combining the lessons of the Chazon Ish and Nesivos Shalom we conclude that genuine Emuna can only manifest itself in a person who is willing to act with an unswerving trust in G-d; a belief that if Ratson Hashem dictates that he act in a certain way, then he can and must take the required action, and that Hashem will enable him to succeed in whatever he endeavors to do. This past Shabbos was the third Yahrzeit of Rav Noach Weinberg zt"l. He epitomized this attribute to a great degree. He is most well-known for his incredible feats in kiruv rechokim (outreach) however, as one of his closest friends pointed out, all his accomplishments emanated directly from his deep Emuna and Bitachon.
I merited to learn in Yeshivas Aish HaTorah for four years, and in that time I was fortunate to experience Rav Weinberg's greatness first-hand. I never forget how he made a bracha - he spoke to Hashem as if He was really in front of Him, a demonstration of 'shivisi Hashem kenegdi tamid' (I constantly place Hashem in front of me) . When he talked about trusting in G-d, it deeply influenced his listeners, not because he said anything so unusual, but because he lived such Bitachon and the fact that he internalized it so greatly enabled it to rub off on others just by observing him.
Because his Emuna was so genuine he was able to apply it in practice and thereby express the high level of proactive Bitachon that the Nesivos Shalom described . He used to say that if we see problems in the world there is no reason that we shouldn't go out and tackle them if we believe that Hashem so desires. Hashem is willing and able to help us achieve his Ratson even if it demands superhuman achievements. If we demonstrate proactive Bitachon then Hashem could make miracles happen for us. This is exactly what took place in Rav Weinberg's life. At a time when kiruv was virtually unheard of, he saw a dire need to bring back the countless Jews who knew nothing of Torah observance. Many people mocked his dreams as being completely unrealistic and called him a fool. Nevertheless, his conviction that he was fulfilling Ratson Hashem enabled him to overcome numerous setbacks and perform miracles in creating a movement that saved thousands upon thousands of unaffiliated Jews from begin totally lost to Judaism . His son, Rav Hillel Weinberg Shlita described how he began his quest with three young men in a small room in Kirayt Sanz. No-one could have imagined how those humble beginnings could culminate in Aish HaTorah and its offshoots. No-one, that is, except for Rav Noach himself; those closest to him testify that he genuinely believed that he would bring Moshiach through his efforts - his extensive achievements were small in his eyes because he knew that Hashem wanted so much more. At the funeral, his son, Rav Hillel, told us what Rav Weinberg would tell us if he were standing in front of us. He would say that we could be bigger than him, we could be as big as Moshe Rabbeinu! Chazal's words to this effect were not some vague saying, rather they were real and should be taken seriously.
I heard an incredible story about how Rav Weinberg put his Emuna into practice; At the shiva his daughter told over that once a chess champion came to Aish, learned for a few days, and decided to leave. Rav Noach challenged him to a game of chess, on the basis that if the student won, he could leave, but if Rav Noach won, he would stay. Rav Noach won. When asked how he could have had the audacity to propose such a deal, he said that he knew Hashem wanted the young man to stay, so he trusted that Hashem would make him win .
It is appropriate to end with one of his oft-told stories, one that I have discussed before, but one that should never fail to arouse us. Many years ago, Rav Shach zt"l came to Aish HaTorah for a bris. Upon seeing numerous baalei teshuva, people who had come from the most distant backgrounds, Rav Shach told over an idea that he had never expressed before . He quoted the Navi, Hoshea; "Return, Yisroel, to Hashem, your G-d because you have stumbled in your sin ." He asked that the Navi implies that the reason that Yisroel should return to Hashem is because they stumbled in sin - why is the stumbling in sin the reason that Yisroel should return to G-d? He answered by explaining that we know that however powerful evil is, the power of good is greater. Accordingly, the very extent to which Yisroel sinned is the proof that they have the power to do teshuva, because however powerful a person's yetser hara, their yetser tov is greater. Based on this, Rav Shach said, that if one man can destroy six million lives, then one man can save six million lives. He was clearly aroused to express this idea by the remarkable feats that Rav Weinberg had already performed. Rav Hillel added, that the man who caused so much destruction, Hitler, yemach shemo, was not a particularly talented or intelligent person and yet he was able to do so much harm. Therefore, each of us, no matter how ordinary we consider ourselves, have the potential to do more good than the evil that he perpetrated. How can we achieve this? By learning from Rav Noach and developing an Emuna and Bitachon that will strengthen us with the belief that we can achieve incredible feats if Hashem so wills it.
It seems difficult to aspire to the level of Emuna and Bitachon that Rav Noach Weinberg attained. However, his greatness in this and all areas did not come about as a result of his natural talent - it was a result of years of hard work in developing his relationship with Hashem. He constantly exhorted us to learn about and internalize the Six Constant Mitzvos, the Mitzvos that encapsulate a Jew's relationship with Hashem. An appropriate way of remembering him would perhaps be to listen to his teachings and strengthen ourselves in our relationship with Hashem through learning about these Mitzvos, beginning with Emuna . This is the key to achieving the level of proactive Bitachon that the Jews reached at Krias Yam Suf and that Rav Noach Weinberg epitomized throughout his life. May we all merit to learn from Rav Noach Weinberg and ensure that his dreams are fulfilled and that every Jew will return to his Father in Heaven.
יתרו – אמנות ההקשבה
בס"ד
יתרו – אמנות ההקשבה יהונתן גפן
אחד הנושאים המפליאים בפרשת יתרו הוא סמיכות פרשיות עצת יתרו ומתן תורה. רבי צדוק הכהן מעניק הבנה מחודשת בעניין זה בשם רבו . בתחילה הוא דן בענין עצת יתרו – יתרו מציע למשה שינויים באופן השפיטה בעם, ומשה מקבל את עצתו. לא נראה שיש משהו יוצא דופן בעניין זה, אולם במבט מעמיק יותר ניתן לגלות מידה מיוחדת במינה של משה רבינו הבאה לידי ביטוי באופן תגובתו לעצת יתרו. ייתכן ויתרו היה אדם חכם מאד, אולם ודאי שדרגתו הייתה נמוכה בהרבה מזו של חתנו הגדול, יתירה מזאת, לא היתה בו את חכמת התורה שהייתה במשה. משה יכול היה בקלות לשמוע את עצתו ולדחותה בעדינות, בלי להעלות בדעתו אפילו להביאה לידי מעשה. אולם, חלף זאת, הוא הקשיב בתשומת לב מרובה הקדיש את מחשבתו לבדוק האם העצה מתאימה וראויה, ובסופו של דבר אף החליט לקבלה ולהשתמש בה. רבו של רבי צדוק אומר שכאן לומדים ממשה שיש לשמוע ולהקשיב גם לדברי הדיוט, כדברי חז"ל: "הלומד מכל אדם". לאחר מכן הוא מסביר את הקשר למתן תורה ואומר שזוהי הקדמה הכרחית לפני מתן תורה כיוון שחלק בלתי נפרד מלימוד התורה הוא היכולת ללמוד ולשמוע מכל אדם.
השאלה שעלולה להתעורר כאן היא, שאמנם היכולת להקשיב לכל אחד חשובה, ובודאי תביא תועלת מרובה ללימוד התורה, אבל בכל זאת עניין זה אינו כל כך משמעותי וחשוב עד שהוא מהווה את ההקדמה שבלעדייה לא ניתן לגשת לעניין מתן תורה. ר' אליהו לופיאן זצ"ל משיב על שאלה זו וכותב שישנם מתמידים גדולים העמלים בתורה, אבל אינם מסוגלים להקשיב לחבריהם וללמוד תורה בדיבוק חברים, אלא הם שקועים עמוק בתוך עצמם ועסוקים בתוך דל"ת אמות שלהם. אנשים כאלה, לא רק שנענשים על אופן התנהגות כזה, אלא גם לימוד התורה שלהם לעולם לא יצלח. הוא ממשיך ומסביר מדוע אדם כזה מעכב ומונע את התפתחותו בלימוד התורה, וכותב שבאופן טבעי אדם "משוחד" לדעה שלו, הוא מצדד בה ומתנגד בעיניים עצומות לכל דעה אחרת. אם לא יסתגל להקשיב לזולת ולשמוע דעות נוספות – הוא לא יצליח להגיע לסברא ישרה ואמיתית .
נראה שהקושי הטבעי, הקיים בכל אדם להקשיב לדעות אחרות, במיוחד כאלה הסותרת את דעתו, עלול למנוע תלמידים גם מהקשבה כהלכה לגדולים מהם. קיימת נטיה מסוימת לחפש מה אפשר לטעון ועל מה ניתן להתווכח בכל מילה ומשפט שרבותיהם אומרים. מה שיוצא מכך הוא שהתלמיד לא קולט בכלל את מה שמלמדים אותו, ובודאי לא מגיע להבנה והפנמה. לעומת זאת, היכולת להקשיב, להכיל ולקבל את דברי הזולת היא אחד המפתחות לגדלות אמיתית.
הסבא מנובהרדוק זצ"ל הדגיש נקודה זו כאשר תיאר את גדלותו של ר' חיים עוזר גרודז'ינסקי זצ"ל: "חכמתו הייתה כה עצומה, עמוקה ורחבה, כיוון שבצעירותו הוא תמיד התאבק בעפרם של גדולי הדור. הוא מעולם לא אמר להם 'קבלו דעתי', אלא הוא עשה עצמו כלי לשמוע ולקבל כל דעה וסברא מכל הגדולים ששהה במחיצתם. הוא ספג לתוך תוכו את כל דברי החכמה ששמע מהם, וכך נזדככה דעתו והתרוממה, מכוח חכמת תורתם של דורות רבים אשר מצאה לה משכן במוחו'" . כאשר אנו מעלים במחשבתנו את גדלותו של ר' חיים עוזר זצ"ל, מה שעולה הוא גאונותו העצומה והיכולת העל אנושית לחשוב על כמה דברים באותו זמן. מדברי הסבא מנובהרדוק רואים שהמפתח לכל הגדלות הזאת היה נכונותו לשמוע כל דבר תורה שנאמר לו.
הקשבה במלא תשומת הלב לדברי רבותינו מהווה אומנם אתגר מסוים, אולם קשה ומאתגרת עוד יותר היא המשימה להקשיב באמת לדברי חברינו. לעיתים קרובות כאשר אי מי בסביבתנו מתחיל לומר רעיון או דבר תורה מסוים, מוחנו מיד מתחיל לחשוב על מה יש לי לומר מיד כאשר הוא יסיים את דבריו. מלבד חוסר הדרך ארץ המופגן בהנהגה כזו, אדם לא יכול לגדול בתורה ולהתעלות כאשר הוא נוהג כך.
היכולת לקבל את דעתו של הזולת, במיוחד כאשר הוא נוגדת את הדעה האישית של השומע היא אכן יכולת נדירה ביותר. במסיבת פרידה אחת, אחד הנואמים הילל ושיבח את מעלותיו של חברו – הוא סיפר שפעם התנהל ביניהם ויכוח לוהט על נושא מסוים, והשיחה הסתימה בלי שהגיעו לעמק השווה. מאוחר יותר, ניגש אליו החבר ואמר לו שהוא מבין מה שהוא רצה לומר, והוא שינה את דעתו על כל העניין בעקבות שיחתם. ישנם שני דברים ראויים לציון בסיפור זה – הראשון הוא יכולתו הגדולה לשמוע השקפה המנוגדת לשלו, ולקבל אותה כאשר היא נראית הגיונית ומתקבלת על הדעת. והשני הוא שמידה מיוחדת זו הייתה כל כך נדירה ובולטת עד כדי כך שזה מה שבחר החבר לספר כאשר תיאר את מעלות חברו. האמת היא, שלא כך אמורים להיות פני הדברים – זה אמור להיות המצב תמיד, כאשר אנו מעורבים בשיחה עם אדם כלשהו, עלינו להקשיב באמת למה שיש לו לומר, ולנסות למצוא מה יש לנו ללמוד ממנו, גם אם לכתחילה דעתו מנוגדת לדעתי.
מה שקשה אף יותר מהקשבה לדברי זולתנו, היא ההקשבה במלא תשומת הלב לדברי הקטנים ממנו בגיל או ברמה. בחור ישיבה בוגר אחד היה מוטרד מדברי המשנה באבות "איזהו חכם, הלומד מכל אדם", לא רק מהגדולים ממנו – הוא הפנה את שאלתו לפוסק, וטען שודאי אין לו מה ללמוד מכאלה שאוחזים ברמות נמוכות בהרבה ממנו בלימוד. תשובת אותו פוסק לכך היתה, שהוא לימד משנה ברורה לבעלי תשובה שאחזו סה"כ שנה אחת אחרי תחילת לימודם. לדבריו, הם התיחסו להלכות מזויות שהוא מעולם לא חשב עליהן לפני כן, ואותם בעלי תשובה הביאו אותו לחשוב ולהגיע ליסודות חדשים רבים בהלכה שהפכו אצלו לנכסי צאן ברזל.
מפרשת יתרו אנו לומדים שהקשבה לזולת היא אחת היסודות הבסיסיים ביותר להגיע לחכמה בכלל, ולחכמת התורה בפרט. מפרשים רבים אומרים שזהו השני מבין מ"ח קניינים שהתורה נקנית בהם – "שמיעת האוזן" – זוהי הדרך לקבל את התורה. מי ייתן ונזכה להגיע ליכולת חשובה זו, להקשיב באמת לדברי רבותינו, חברינו ותלמידינו, ועל ידי כך נצליח בע"ה ללמוד ולהבין את התורה הקדושה.
YISRO - INSIGHTS IN RASHI – SANCTIFYING G-D’S NAME
YISRO - INSIGHTS IN RASHI – SANCTIFYING G-D’S NAME
Shemos, 18:1: “Yisro, the priest of Midian, the father-in-law of Moshe, heard everything that G-d did to Moshe and to Israel, His people – that HaShem had taken Israel out of Egypt.”
Rashi, Shemos, 18:1, sv. And Yisro heard: “What news did he hear that he came? The splitting of the Yam Suf and the war against Amalek.”
Rashi points out two events that played a defining role in Yisro’s momentous decision to join the Jewish people; krias Yam Suf and the war against Amalek. The Be’er Yosef asks that it is understandable that Krias Yam Suf inspired Yisro to convert. It was a momentous occasion in which HaShem’s presence was revealed through open miracles. However, the battle with Amalek was far less inspiring – although Divine Providence was apparent, it was far less earth-shattering than the other miracles. Moreover, there were times in the battle when Amalek was on the ascendancy, with the result that this battle seemed more ‘natural’ than the other events of the Exodus (Yetsias Mitzrayim). If they were insufficient to arouse Yisro to convert, how could this battle achieve anything more?!
He begins his answer by acknowledging that it was not the miraculous nature of the battle with Amalek that inspired Yisro. In fact it was the detrimental effect this battle had that prompted him to join the Jewish people: The nations of the world were greatly moved by the miracles of Yetsias Mitzrayim, as it says in the Song of the Sea, “Then the chieftains of Edom were confounded, trembing gripped the powers of Moav, all the dwellers of Canaan dissolved.” However, when Amalek attacked, they reduced the feelings of awe that the world had towards the Jewish nation. They now did not see the Jews as invincible, and their respect for G-d’s people cooled down. This is expressed by Chazal in their analogy of a boiling hot bath that no-one will jump into. Suddenly a man jumps in and gets burnt, but he cools down the water. Even though Amalek were defeated, they did have moments when they were successful, and seeing such a regular kind of battle succeeded in diluting the effects of the miracles of Yetsias Mitzrayim. Thus the attack of Amalek had the opposite effect of the miracles.
How did that prompt Yisro to convert? The Be’er Yosef continues that Yisro’s overriding consideration was the effect that the battle with Amalek would have on HaShem’s name in the world. Had Amalek not attacked then Yisro may have sufficed with being a Noachide Jew (Ben Noach) and observing the Jews with admiration and he surely hoped that the rest of the world would do the same. However, after this attack Yisro felt the need to publicly join the Jewish people to demonstrate that the nations should still have great awe for the Jewish nation. He was a very well-known figure in the world and he realized that his journey from Midian to the desert would be widely viewed. In addition Chazal tell us that he went to great lengths to publicize his joining the Jews. The Medrash says us that HaShem Himself told Moshe that Yisro’s intentions were totally pure. The Be’er Yosef explains that the purity of his intentions was manifest by his desire to counter the negative effect that Amalek had.
The question remains; did Yisro succeed in all his efforts to sanctify G-d’s name among the nations of the world. The Zohar answers this: “When Yisro, who was the high priest of idolatry, said, ‘Now I know that HaShem is greater than all gods,’ the honor of the Holy One, Blessed is He, rose and was given dominion over all. Because [Yisro] served the Holy One, Blessed is He, everyone immediately distanced themselves from their idolatry, [for they] realized that there was no truth in it. Then the Name of the Holy One, Blessed is He, was sanctified throughout the world.”
Yisro taught us a great lesson in his journey to becoming a Jew. It is not enough to think about one’s own relationship with HaShem but how one can effect others as well. In this vein Rav Chaim of Volozhin zt”l writes that in the Shemoneh Esrei of Rosh Hashana we say that Hashem judges the “maaseh ish upekudaso”. Maaseh ish means a person’s own actions, but what does ‘pekudaso’ refer to? He explains that each person has a sphere of influence beyond himself, which includes his family, his students, and any people that come into contact with him. The way he influences these people through his own actions is ‘pekudaso’ and he is judged in that area as well. If, by observing his behaviour, they learn to improve their avodas Hashem then he will receive much reward but if the opposite occurs then he will be judged for his part in their aveiros just as he is judged for his own . A person’s actions do not take place in a vacuum, we are always being noticed by others, consequently we must constantly be aware of the possible effect we can have on others without even directly communicating with them. Yisro recognized this fact and acted upon it – thus he stands as a shining example to us all.
Sunday, January 20, 2013
TU B'SHVAT - APPRECIATING HASHEM'S WORLD
The first Mishna in the gemara of Rosh Hashana informs us of various 'new years'. These are times of the year that are considered the beginning of the annual calendar with regard to various laws. The Rosh Hashana for trees is the fifteenth day of the month of Shvat, more famously known as 'Tu B'Shvat'. This day is considered a festive day, therefore the prayer of tachanun (supplication for forgiveness) is not recited. Further, there is the universal custom to make blessings on, and, eat a variety of fruit. The overall focus of the day is to thank HaShem for the gift of trees to the world and to recognize the wonders of nature.
Rav Yaakov Weinberg zt"l asks, why is there no similar concept of a celebratory day for the 'birthday' of vegetables? There is also a date for the new year for vegetables which has halachic (legal) ramifications. That being the case, why is there no festivity on their 'birthday' ? He explains that there are numerous remarkable aspects about nature, that merit contemplation of the wonder of creation. Many 'miracles' occur with regard to both vegetables and trees. For example, the taking root of a seed and its development into a tree, bush or vegetable is truly miraculous - it is only its regularity that takes away from our wonder at this astonishing occurrence. Moreover, the process of photosynthesis that enables plant life to use the energy from the sun is another miracle that demonstrates the complexity of nature.
However, there is an additional miracle that is found specifically with trees. The process of nourishment for a vegetable is relatively straightforward; it is drawn directly from the ground into the vegetable itself. In contrast, the process of nourishment for a tree is far more complicated. The tree needs to be able to take the nourishment from the ground, draw it all the way up the trunk to its branches, and then to the fruit. Rav Weinberg explains that every stage in a plant's development is a miracle, therefore we are instructed to be thankful for HaShem's numerous gifts in this area. Since trees are subject to more miracles than vegetables, it is appropriate that their 'birthday' is considered more worthy of celebration than that of vegetables.
Rav Weinberg's explanation reminds us of the importance of focusing on the details of creation - it is very easy to ignore the numerous miraculous aspects of all of the natural world. Tu B'Shvat awakens us to the importance of appreciating HaShem's gifts, particularly in the form of fruit. It is instructive to offer one small example of this, in order to arouse us to take note of the numerous miracles that surround us.
When a person eats a peach, he pays little attention to the hard stone that lies beneath the tasty fruit. However, Rav Avraham Katz shlita teaches us about the great significance of this seemingly bland aspect of nature. Like all fruit, the peach has a great problem - that is, how to ensure its continuity. Since it is completely immobile it has no way of spreading its seed so that it can procreate. Therefore, the peach seed develops a tasty flesh that surrounds it. This will cause humans and animals to eat the peach, thereby transferring it to other locations where it may be able to take root. However, there remains the difficulty of how the seed will not be consumed by its eater along with the rest of the fruit. Accordingly, the peach seed surrounds itself with a very hard casing that cannot be broken by the strongest teeth. In this way, the precious seed is safe. Nevertheless, the problems do not end there. If the casing is so strong, how will the seed be able escape so that it can take root? The remarkable answer to this, is that the casing is lined with a seam running along its length, which is bounded by a powerful adhesive. Not even a metal hammer is able to crack it. And yet, when the case falls to the ground, there is a special enzyme in the soil that dissolves the glue and allows the seed to exit its casing! This mundane seed is the subject of numerous miracles, and if any of them did not take place, then the peach would cease to exist. This is just one example of the testimony to the wonders of HaShem's creation.
On Tu B'Shvat we take numerous fruits and say blessings on them before we eat them. This custom can help us focus on the numerous acts of kindness that HaShem performs for us in ensuring the creation of these wonderful fruit. As a person goes through his daily routine, it is very easy for him to inadvertently close his eyes to the wonders around him. The analogy is given of a person who visits the Louvre art gallery, and complains that all the paintings look like yoghurt. After some time, he takes off his glasses, only to realize that they had yoghurt on them! He was unable to appreciate the beauty of the paintings because his vision was blocked. So too, a person can go through life with the proverbial 'yoghurt' blocking his vision, causing him to be blind to the numerous marvels that surround him. Tu B'Shvat gives us the opportunity to open our eyes and appreciate some of HaShem's wonderful gifts.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)